Welcome home Cannon, and CONGRATULATIONS on the 5 pounds!! That is VERY cool!
I absolutely agree with you, every time I'm in a situation where I know what I *would* have eaten in the past, compared to whatever choice I now make, I am blown away by how many calories I must have consumed without giving it a second thought. Two doughnuts - NO PROBLEM...
Good for you for sticking with option #3! Feeling deprived is no way to live!