What an entertaining thread!  
Couldn't sleep, having some intense pain so started reading & found this.   :yelrotflmao:  I am laughing so much I forgot my leg (for a while)
I used to just LOVE 
Heroes when no one seemed to know about it & I was the only one in my immediate grp that was bonkers about some crazy show.   I just adored Hiro, thought he was cuter than a button (whatever that means.)   Now he almost seems as stupid acting as Peter (& in real life he is suppposed to have a very high IQ)  It all was so new & exciting in the 1st couple of seasons,  it never bored me.   I taped every show I coudn't watch.   Sylar was fascinating, as well as the two sides of the evil:devil:/loving:cheeky: dad.  They really nailed the archetype of flaws in evey persona.  BTW, what happened to Sylar's *hunger* now that he is trying to be a good boy??   I never could figure out what Mrs. Pretrelli had to do w/ everything, but you knew future episodes where going to reveal more things about her.  Although the reversal of roles has been entertaining, I have to agree w/Typhon in post #42, & I've gotten tired of it now.  :drooling1:  I sincerely hope it gets better!
Since I never got to see or even know about 
Lost when it first came out, I am hooked by that show now!   It's on the same time as 
Heroes 
so I flip over to it on commercials & can tell what's going on, especially if I watch parts of it on the 
Heroes' web site.
I don't have Showtime, but really got into 
Californication  when it was on for free.  Don't have the budget for that until I make some changes.   I peeked at 
Smallville last Mon. & the time for the birth of Superman has come, I believe.  The development of that character will probably be for the rest of this season.  
Loved 
House until I got bored by it being on EVERY DAY, sometimes all day long (like some other nameless shows I am sick of.) 

  I am just starting to get a kick out of 
Fringe & 
Eleventh Hour, I'll have to watch more before I pass judgment, however, & see how silly they get.