Sure, it's probably not optimal, but for someone starting out or just looking to keep toned and get some cardio, it's not a bad place to start. As you said, it's working for me (and several others I know there), and that's what matters most.
Literally anything that gets you moving more than you were previously, 'works'.
If this type of atmosphere is something that appeals to you and your friends, than I think it's great. Really.
I just like people to make informed decisions.
I'd be willing to bet that the vast majority of those joining Curves and Curves-esque types of joints aren't informed.
And that certainly isn't the fault of the gym.
But they certainly take advantage of the ignorance and that's where they lose my respect for the most part.
And at $34 a month--it's very affordable.
Indeed.
I checked out the Y before joining, and it's $60 a month. When my finances improve, I will probably start going there.
That's steep.
My current gym is probably the nicest I've ever seen and it's not even that much.