I don't have space in a pm for this, and maybe it's more relevant to put it here anyway.
Self-Criticism
I think criticism can be another word for assessment, and I think self-assessment is required for us to make changes in our lives. Otherwise why would we make changes? How would we know whether the changes are the ones we want?
Attacking ourselves, hating ourselves, putting ourselves down in harsh ways - these are different to healthy self criticism and do damage to ourselves just as much as they would damage our children if we treated them that way. I agree that it can lock us in to negative patterns. I think at times, we can damage ourselves with self hate without even being consciously aware of that. I'm quite sure I've done that. When I was here last year I wrote about a confusing moment I had while I was fighting a potential binge, and over the past months I've often been reminded of that moment. (It's
here but geez such a long post and barely relevant - it was just the start of my awareness). I think I've recovered, but I do keep going back and poking the spot because I see I'm not perfectly achieving everything I want, and I like to make sure that's not the reason. I don't want it sneaking up on me again.
I suppose I could try to counteract it with affirmations to myself, and I might do that, though today I have a pretty long to do list and for the near future I have an even longer one. Even deciding to add an affirmation would mean doing a bunch of mental juggling. I suppose it would be like adding a new piece of paper to my messy office type area and trying to decide where to file it. So I will just put the consideration down on-line as a draft file - I'll get to it.
Part of what I'm trying to do as I recover is to keep making progress with a bunch of different parts of my life that are all important to me - weight loss and personal growth are only two of a bigger number. I don't want any of them to get out of control and end up punching me in the head. I'm trying to make changes slowly across a range of parts of my life. LOL. No I'm not - I'm trying to make changes fast across a range of parts of my life, but I only have so much time in the day and I'm trying to practice the discipline of attending to all of them. So that makes some of them reasonably slow, the way they probably should be anyway. I'm a person that loves to follow my inclinations to their extremes, and I don't want to lose that altogether, but I want to be very careful about how I handle it. I think that's critical for me to maintain a weight loss long term.
do you think people who love themselves and their bodies neither abuse themselves nor others?
That seems reasonable - like it makes sense that it would be true. I don't have any personal experience or knowledge of studies or stories that would contradict that. On the other hand I know that people who hate themselves may abuse themselves or others. It would be a hard thing to actually be sure about though.
I can imagine a person who does love herself and her body but has a few insecurities about what she's capable of, and yet wishes to achieve something she's not sure she can manage. (Maybe something like starting a new type of work, or taking a promotion.) She could be safe and not try, or take a risk and give it a go. Maybe she could even believe it was something she could well cope with, then find out she'd been misled about what was required. While she's in the area she's not sure about, she might react badly to the way someone else treats her.
Yes, the love herself thing would impact but what if she gets snowed under with a lot of conflicting demands and a short timeline? What if she's also under physical stress - sudden back pain? Even if she decided it would be more loving to herself to leave, she might be caught in a position where she was responsible for carrying on for a while, regardless of feeling inadequate, and leaving would cause distress to other people. I guess we could say that during that time, she would be loving herself less and that would be why she might make a bad decision that hurts someone else, or stress out and speak meanly to them. Still she might have been loving herself to start with. That's just a fairly simple example. Real life is more complex.
I guess I think that generalizations like the love one, can give us some big clues about useful behaviors, without being the whole story.