Steve, I guess it's hard for someone to understand the psychology of someone like me who's tried and failed so many times. You have a problem putting on weight, and while I sympathize, that's not the same as being 70 lbs. overweight, getting high blood pressure and all sorts of other problems from it, and especially failing so many times.
When you're 25 you pretty much figure you can do anything. When you're my age, you have a much closer acquaintance with your own mortality. On the one hand, I have a lot of confidence I can do this right this time. On the other hand, I'm scared to death of the consequences of failing yet again. I don't think my body can handle too many more of these giant weight fluctuations; in fact, I know it can't.
So yeah, to you a few pounds is nothing. And really it IS nothing. But the previous 8 times I tried and failed, the start of reverting back to the way I was was regaining some of the pounds I lost. Sorry, but when I see that, it's hard to deal with. It's a pattern that freaks me out a bit. My guess is that if you were 30 years older than you are now, and had been through this cycle as many times as I have, you would tend to get a bit freaked out yourself.
I'm not asking you to get your violin out here. I'm just trying to explain why it's difficult for me to deal with this. We all have our "triggers" - the things that freak us out more than they ought to. I'm well aware of my triggers, and I'm fighting them, too. But that doesn't make them disappear. They're my personal demons, and part of this battle is learning how to deal with them, not pretending they don't exist.
I understand what you're saying about this struggle not being a "linear progression." God knows I have enough data on my spreadsheets to show exactly that. But we all have to realize that it's not a linear progression psychologically, either, particularly when it comes to our personal demons. Expecting that someone will progress psychologically in a linear fashion is no more realistic than expecting the same thing physiologically.
And, as you know, physiology and psychology are intertwined in ways that we barely understand. That's one of the reasons 95% of all people fail in this struggle. They can deal with one or the other, but the combination of them both usually proves to be an insurmountable obstacle.
Do I think I'll be in that 5% category that will succeed? You bet I do! At the same time, I'm running scared. It's not the same thing as when I did this for the sake of vanity or some vague notion of being healthy. It's a very different feeling, believe me. It's what motivates me to work out harder than 95% of the people I see in the gym. But it's also what can make me a bit "obsessive."
Do I dwell on this too much? Yes and no. I'm trying to deal with it by talking about it in about as public a way as possible -- something I never, ever imagined I would do 6 months ago. It may turn some people off -- and if it does, those people shouldn't waste another second reading my journal. But it may help others, because they may have the same demons I do.
One might read my journal and look at all the workouts and think, "gee, he's having a pretty easy time of it. . . losing 3 pounds a month, working out six days a week, good blood pressure. . . what's the big deal?" And it's true, I have a blessed life. I have nothing to complain about. But that doesn't mean I don't have to struggle with some of the same old ugly demons that everyone else does.
I write about them here partly to flush them out, and partly to encourage others who have them that they, too, can win this battle.