Mineralwasser vs. Leitungswasser

Hallo,
wollte nur mal fragen was ihr zu dieser Gegenüberstellung sagt. Ich trinke eigentlich nur Leitungswasser, denn auch mit Soda-Club wird dem Leitungswasser nur Kohlensäure zugesetzt, aber keine Mineralien usw. Was is jetzt gesünder bzw. kann es sein, daß bei reinem Leitungswasserkonsum dem Körper sogar was "fehlt".. ich hoffe ihr wisst was ich meine
Gruß
 
Du kannst ruhig Leitungswasser statt Mineralwasser trinken, hauptsache es ist nicht allzu kalkhaltig (kann man erfragen)
 
Original geschrieben von Dr.Jones
Du kannst ruhig Leitungswasser statt Mineralwasser trinken, hauptsache es ist nicht allzu kalkhaltig (kann man erfragen)

was stört kalk im Wasser? Ich wohne in München und hier ist mega viel kalk im wasser so weit ich weiss... :eek:


PS: Und jetzt kommt mir nicht damit, dass ich total verkalkt werde :D :D :D
 
@Defi: hast du's schon mal gekostet ? nix schmeckt so rein und so flüssig wie aqua dest. und unser allerliebstes bier wird auch damit hergestellt.

Gruss Skyguide
 
:eek: :eek: :eek:

Dest-Wasser? Hab's zwar noch nicht probiert, aber gesund kann's nicht sein. Zum einen aus osmotischen Gründen und wie willst Du Deinen Mineraliengehalt sonst decken?

Hab mal gelesen, dass eine Zufuhr von 2l Dest-wasser Blutungen im Magen und Darm verursachen kann !?

Gruss,
D.
 
Ich bin ja kein Arzt , :D , aber die fehlende Deckung des Eletrolytbedarfes und die von Poly angesprochenen Riskiken sind nicht von der Hand zu weisen..
 
@Poly: Naja, mehr als 1.5l trinke ich davon auch kaum pro Tag :).

Einer meiner Schüler ist Zahnarzt. Er wollte mir erklären, dass die tödlich ist, aber ich beweise das Gegenteil :D.


@All: Hmm, dann erklärt mir mal, wie das denn in USA und Asien funktionieren soll, wo alle destilliertes Wasser trinken ?

Mal abgesehen davon, wer sagt denn, dass die Mineralien im schönen Mineralwasser vom Körper aufgenommen werden können ? Ich trinke absichtlich immer mineralienarmes Wasser z.B. Evian.

Die Mineralstoffversorgung garantiere ich durch die Ernährung (Früchte, Gemüse).

Gruss Skyguide
 
also...
keiner sagt, das die mineralien vom körper aufgenommen werden. aber dieses wasser entzieht keine salze und keine mineralien, weil es schon gesättigt ist.

ich fahr jetzt mal schnell zu einem arzt und lass mir das für dich erklären. also bei einem bin ich mir 100%ig sicher:
destilliertes wasser entzieht dem körper salze!!

greetz hurri

fange jetzt mein training an :)
 
Mhhh, mit dem Kalk im Wasser schmeckt super und hab irgendwo gelesen dass es gut für die Knochen ist...
Nicht umsonst gehört das Münchner Wasser ja zu den besten in Deutschland *mitstolzgeschwellterbrustsag* :D
 
in den USA und Asien trinken die kein destilliertes Wasser. Die trinken fast ausschließlich Wasser aus der Leitung und das ist mit Chlor versetzt. D.h. es schmeckt nach Schwimmhalle :)
 
Hier was dazu, leider in english:


Does distilled water leach minerals from my body?

Absolutely, not...in fact just the opposite has been found to occur in cellular research studies. It is a mistaken belief that drinking pure distilled water reduces valuable minerals from living human tissues.

There are two types of minerals, organic and inorganic. Human physiology has a biological affinity for organic minerals. Most organic minerals for our body functions come from dietary plant foods. A growing plant converts the inorganic minerals from the soils to a useful organic mineral.

Tap water presents a variety of inorganic minerals which our body has difficulty absorbing. Their presence is suspect in a wide array of degenerative diseases, such as hardening of the arteries, arthritis, kidney stones, gall stones, glaucoma, cataracts, hearing loss, emphysema, diabetes, and obesity. What minerals are available, especially in "hard" tapwater, are poorly absorbed, or rejected by cellular tissue sites, and, if not evacuated, their presence may cause arterial obstruction, and internal damage Even if the human tissue suddenly developed the ability to absorb inorganic minerals from tap water, it would take an enormous amount of tapwater to supply the bare minimal mineral quantities for human life functions. If (for example) the rich inorganic mineral content of the tap water in Reno, Nevada were modified so that it would convert the daily Calcium requirement (RDA) from its inorganic calcium solutes, you would have to drink 7.4 gallons of their tap water!

When inorganic minerals are "removed" from tapwater, by converting it into pure distilled water, the result is a remarkable biological mineral absorption for both health and maximal metabolic activity.

(This is an edited version of Dr Bill Misner's answer to the question above)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Aren’t there minerals missing from distilled water that my body needs?

There is no doubt that the body needs minerals. This issue is perhaps the ‘hottest’ one regarding the use of distilled water. It is easy to find an equal number of ‘authorities’ or ‘experts’ on both sides of this controversial issue.

In short, virtually all nutritional and medical authorities agree that the body assimilates organic minerals from the daily food cycle. Where the authorities disagree is whether or not the body directly extracts any nutritional value from the minerals found in an inorganic source such as dissolved rocks, dirt, and stone found in tap or mineral waters.

Perhaps the best way we have found to sort out this problem is to evaluate various tap and mineral water sources around the world and determine the amount of inorganic minerals (by weight) which would be consumed by drinking an average of two liters of tap water daily. Then, we compare this number to the amount of minerals (by weight) found in a normal daily diet. Dr. Jon Kirschmann’s Nutritional Almanac is one of several good sources for this data.

When these two sources of minerals are compared, the results are real eye-openers. On the average, over 95% of the major and trace minerals ingested daily (by weight) come from food (fruits, vegetables, animal products) - and less than 5% from drinking water.

The distilled water ‘mineral issue’ then can be focused into a much clearer question: Is it really smart to ingest all types of heavy metals, bacteria, chemicals used in water treatment processes, industrial and agricultural chemical residues, etc. simply to get that little additional percentage of daily mineral intake from water sources. We don’t think so!

But don’t just take our word for it, listen to what the experts say…

"The body’s need for minerals is largely met through foods, not drinking water."

American Medical Journal

"The minerals which the human body needs that are in the water are insignificant to those in food… and anyone simply eating a varied diet, not even a balanced diet, could hardly suffer a mineral deficiency."

Dr. Henry A. Schroeder, Dartmouth Medical School

"Water hardness (inorganic minerals in solution) is the underlying cause of many, if not all, of the diseases resulting from poisons in the intestinal tract. These (hard minerals) pass from the intestinal walls and get into the lymphatic system, which delivers all of its products to the blood, which in turn, distributes to all parts of the body. This is the cause of much human disease."

Dr. Charles Mayo, world-renowned Mayo Clinic

"The only minerals that the body can utilize are the organic minerals. All other types of minerals are foreign substances to the body and must be eliminated. Distilled water is the only water that can be taken into the body without any damage to the tissues."

The Choice is Clear…by Dr. Allen E. Banik

"The greatest damage done by inorganic minerals - plus waxy cholesterol and salt - is to the small arteries and other blood vessels of the brain (75% water). Hardening of the arteries and calcification of the blood vessels starts on the day you start taking inorganic chemicals and minerals from the tap water into you bodies."

The Shocking Truth About Water…by Dr. Paul Bragg, ND.Ph.D .



Gruss Skyguide
 
In Deutschland sind die Qualitätsansprüche an Leitungswasser höher als die ans Mineralwasser. Von der Sauberkeit her, ist man [theoretisch] also mit Leitungswasser auf dem sicheren Pfad...
 
So und jetzt mal ausführlich:

DISTILLED WATER ENHANCES MINERAL ABSORPTION

By DR. BILL MISNER, Ph.D.

DOES DISTILLED WATER LEACH MINERALS FROM OUR BODIES?

Absolutely, not...in fact just the opposite has been found to occur in cellular research studies. It is a mistaken belief that drinking pure distilled water reduces valuable minerals from living human tissues.

ORGANIC MINERALS VS. INORGANIC MINERALS

There are two types of minerals, organic and inorganic. Human physiology has a biological affinity for organic minerals. Most organic minerals for our body functions come from dietary plant foods. A growing plant converts the inorganic minerals from the soils to a useful organic mineral. When an organic mineral (from a plant food) enters the stomach it must attach itself to a specific protein-molecule (chelation) in order to be absorbed, then it gains access to the tissue sites where it is needed. Once a plant mineral is divested within the body, it is utilized as a coenzyme for composing body fluids, forming blood and bone cells, and the maintaining of healthy nerve transmission. (Balch & Balch 1990)

Without a healthy organic mineral balance inside and outside the cells of muscle, blood, and bone substructures, the body will began to spasm, twitch and cramp, eventually deteriorating to a full "rigor complex", and/or complete failure.

INORGANIC MINERALS FROM TAPWATER ARE "BAD NEWS".

Tap water presents a variety of inorganic minerals which our body has difficulty absorbing. Their presence is suspect in a wide array of degenerative diseases, such as hardening of the arteries, arthritis, kidney stones, gall stones, glaucoma, cataracts, hearing loss, emphysema, diabetes, and obesity. What minerals are available, especially in "hard" tapwater, are poorly absorbed, or rejected by cellular tissue sites, and, if not evacuated, their presence may cause arterial obstruction, and internal damage. (Dennison 1993, Muehling 1994, Banik 1989)

ORGANIC MINERALS ARE PREFERRED...

Is it any wonder why the body prefers the richest source of mineral substrates from organic foods instead of the mineral-poor sources from tap water? Even if the human tissue suddenly developed the ability to absorb inorganic minerals from tap water, it would take an enormous amount of tapwater to supply the bare minimal mineral quantities for human life functions. If (for example) the rich inorganic mineral content of the tap water in Reno, Nevada were modified so that it would convert the daily Calcium requirement (RDA) from its inorganic calcium solutes, one would have to drink 7.4 gallons of their tap water!

HOW DISTILLED WATER ENHANCES MINERAL ABSORPTION RATES

Distilled Pure Water will not conduct electricity when only 2 parts inorganic minerals or less are present. Water with 5 parts inorganic content per million parts water (or more) will conduct electricity, completing a simple circuit and lighting a tester bulb! The higher the inorganic content is in a per million count, the less effectively water transmits organic minerals to tissue sites. Bottled water, tapwater, reverse-osmosis filtered water, and carbon-block filtered water (when tested) will conduct electricity, substantiating that each one is not the best carrier for the mineral-transport and mineral-absorption (Muehling 1994). Our tapwater in the USA has been shown to contain 19 "inorganic metals of concern"(1994 Safe Water Drinking Act), for which maximum contaminant levels have been set. (Tone 1994) Most American tapwater tested falls between the ranges of 350 parts per million to over 1000 parts per million total contaminants! (Colgan 1993)

REPEAT THE QUESTION PLEASE...

Does drinking distilled water leach the minerals from the body? No, quite the opposite...if inorganic minerals are "removed" from tapwater, by converting it into pure distilled water, the result is remarkable biological mineral absorption for both health and maximal metabolic activity. The application of this query has a remarkably high correlation to the general properties of maximal absorption rates, for all micronutrients which traverse the gastric chambers directly into the muscle cells for premium performance demand.

REFERENCES

Muehling EC, "Pure Water Now: Its Time For Action," 2cd Ed., Pure Water Inc., Lincoln, Neb., 1994:1-42.

Dennison C, "Why I Drink Distilled Water", Reprint Form 6300, Pure Water Inc., Lincoln, Neb.,1993.

Tone J, "Your Drinking Water-How Good Is It?", National Testing Laboratories Inc., Cleveland, Ohio,1994:21.

Banik AE, "The Choice Is Clear," ACRES USA, Metaire, Louisiana, 1989:37.

Balch JF, Balch PA, PRESCRIPTION FOR NUTRITIONAL HEALING, Avery Publishing Co., Garden City, NY, 1990:17.

Colgan M, OPTIMUM SPORTS NUTRITION, Advanced Research Press, New York, NY, 1993:23-24.
 
Zurück
Oben