Maybe she's well-respected because she speaks her mind? If she's otherwise well-respected, it really sounds like a problem you and her need to discuss one-on-one in order to resolve the issue, even if you don't want to give her name publically. *shrug* If you aren't specific concerning who you're talking about, how is she ever going to realize she has hurt your feelings if it's unintentional? I've met a couple different mods on this forum and don't believe any of them, no matter how blunt some of them have the capacity to be, are out for blood.
Ditto.
I think so, too.
Salt may not be all that great in your diet, but if I were you, I'd take EVERYTHING with a grain of salt here. I don't care whose talkin'.
I'm sure there are people in every forum on the planet whose joy in life is to make people look stupid, but some (though surely not all) of the "negative" feedback I suspect is being targeted in this thread is really only people being honest, and telling it like it is. It's much easier to be honest with people when you don't know them and don't have to tell them to their face. This honesty can definitely work to your advantage if you use it (instead of being abused by it) and don't take it personally.
As far as support goes, supporting people does not always mean coddling them or walking on eggshells around their tender feelings. Lots of people here are in their current state of bad health because people in their lives were trying to be supportive of them (and tactful of their weight problems). Nobody wants to be the person to say: Hey, put down the fork, you're digging your grave with it.
Because nobody (well...ALMOST nobody) wants to be negative. People's feelings get hurt. Sometimes certain people in here can seem negative, harsh, or even a little cruel, but many of them are trying to look out for your best interest in the best way they can, whether it bruises egos or not.
I haven't been part of this forum very long, but I've been criticized a few times by people in here, for various things. The thing to keep in mind is that you can learn much more from people you disagree with and/or don't like than from people you do.
The best thing to do (imho, anyway) is to forget about tone. Just take in the information, and double-check it if you don't think it's right. That's the greatest way to self improve. And the more you improve yourself, the higher your self-esteem will become.
Self-esteem shouldn't be dependent on the opinions of people you don't even really know. It should come from within yourself.
It's all a matter of perspective. If I say something harsh and nobody calls me out on it, I don't automatically assume that people approve of what I've said - but it's kind of silly to go around seething because you think someone is being "negative" if you don't call them out on it to clarify, because emotion IS difficult to read in text. Chances are, they didn't even mean to hurt anyone's feelings, only inform to the best of their ability (which, admittedly, is sometimes not very good, depending on the person and the subject).
There is no reason to be intimidated by ANYONE in an online forum. I don't care how ignorant of weight loss issues or sensitive you are (not that I'm calling anyone here ignorant or sensitive-strictly speaking in the hypothetical here).
I mean, you don't know any of these people. How seriously can you take their opinions, really? It's not like they're cutting you down in front of your friends and family or dragging you around by the ear like a wayward pup who piddled on the carpet, just voicing their opinions from out of the cyber ether.
Maybe there are just people who are more delicate than I am, but I don't find any person online intimidating in the least. Nobody I know online, friend or foe, has any real bearing on my life, other than the advice they have to give. And then only if *I* choose to take it.
Even in everyday life, you always have the choice to say Screw That! Nobody, no matter how knowledgable, can take that power from you.
And THAT'S called self-esteem, people.
(On a completely separate note, I frickin' LOVE me some rollercoasters.

)