Weight loss plan not working..

I'm a 17-year-old female (5'4"-5") and I weight 147lbs. I'm hoping to lose between 20 and 30 pounds in time for summer. At the end of October, I got myself one of those "mini stepper" machines, because I don't really have many other means of exercise where I live.

I have a maintenance line of about 2000+ calories or so, and I'm trying to keep my daily calore intake as 1,500. Every night, I do half an hour on the stepper, and according to its built-in calorie estimator, I burn about 250 calories per session.

However, I have been doing this for about three months now, and not much has happened -- if anything, I feel much fatter. There have been days where I've skipped, or had a bit more to eat, but most of the time I'm reasonably good.

I don't know why anything hasn't happened yet. Does anyone have any tips? I've also been told by a friend that when you first start exercising regularly, you will get heavier as muscle mass builds up. But when does the actual fat-burning start?

I have no idea if the problem's in my routine, or I just have to be patient and keep going at it; I hope someone could give me a little bit of good news/advice, heh. :p
 
I'm a 17-year-old female (5'4"-5") and I weight 147lbs. I'm hoping to lose between 20 and 30 pounds in time for summer. At the end of October, I got myself one of those "mini stepper" machines, because I don't really have many other means of exercise where I live.

What about walking, running, or bicycling (outside)?

You can even be time efficient by doubling up your exercise with commuting. E.g. walk, run, or bicycle to school (or work). Walk up the stairs instead of using the elevator or escalator.

However, I have been doing this for about three months now, and not much has happened -- if anything, I feel much fatter.

How do you feel fatter? Has your waist measurement changed?
 
I have no idea if the problem's in my routine, or I just have to be patient and keep going at it; I hope someone could give me a little bit of good news/advice, heh. :p

As far as I can tell, basal metabolic rate can vary from person to person by as much as +/- 500 calories or more. It's entirely possible that you are overestimating your caloric needs and underestimating your calorie intake with the net effect of remaining at or above your maintenance while thinking you're in a deficit.

To start, I would recommend making certain that your intake numbers are on target... What have you eaten in the last 3 days? In as much detail as possible. When, what, how much. After you've made sure of that, I'd recommend trying dropping your calories down by 250/day and seeing if that makes any difference.

There are also the issues of variety and intensity. If you are doing the same bit of cardio every day and never changing it up, well, that's not going to do much to stimulate the sort of physiological changes you want. This cardio you do for half an hour every night, are you progressing continually? Y'know, faster, better, harder, stronger?

Do you do any strength training? I hear that you don't have much in the way of equipment or access to a gym (it sounds like), but you can do quite a surprising lot with nothing but your own body. Adding just a quick 10 minute training session every other day might yield some results.
 
I can see your problem. It is diet. You are stuck on a diet mentality and that is your problem. You don't need to do worthless calories counting/tracking. Throw away your calories book, and don't focus on how many calories you're eating/burning. In the end, you're only hurting yourself when you count calories, skip meals, binge eating, etc. So, the first step to a healthier you is to throw away the diet thinking, and start thinking in terms of what you like to eat, what you can change, etc. Now I'm not saying go outside and go nuts eating loads of cakes and ice cream. No, I'm saying just don't fall into the trap of dieting. Put no limit as your limit. Put all food as your food. Make all wants satisfied. Make all meals happy. When you do this, you will automatically follow a 90-10 rule (and even that rule can be broken without stressing yourself out), and on top of that you will automatically follow a 5 meals rule - that is eating every 2-4 hours. Therefore, I urge you to not go the calories tracking route, and rethink your overall eating such that it fits around you. In order to burn calories, you must have the resources to make your body want to burn stored fat - to get this, you need to be eating and always being full.

Yes, exercising can build muscle, which would mean more weight. But I doubt that is the case here being that you're three months in and seeing limited progress. What is happening, is that you're not exercising any more than what you are doing at nights with the stair steppers. You need to start being more active. This means physically doing things rather than trying to cut down. Things like walking up the steps, walking around the block, and even doing house work is considered good. Remember, you don't have to be hardcore, sweating like some crazy animal to be getting a decent exercise. Healthy people simply are more active than unhealthy, obese people. Remember, find things that are fun to do, and stick with it. If you don't like the stair stepping machine, then throw it away. You don't need it. You got the world to yourself, and I say go out and enjoy it.

Another problem I see with you is that you're setting goals based on weight rather than becoming a healthier you. When you base success or failure on weight, it always fails. Why? Simple: weight go up and down. Weight scales poke fun at you. It laughs, and it cries for attention because it knows you love to see the number change. Step on the scale, then go drink a cup of water, hop back on the scale,boom you just gained five pounds, then wait a few hours, hop back on the scale, you lost weight. Don't concern with your weight. Throw away your scale and you'll see you feel a lot better about yourself when you don't have constant concern on weights, calories, and other things. When you drop the diet mentality - that is you stop dieting, stop worrying about calories, and stop worrying about weight - then you will naturally maintain a healthy weight for your age. Also, you're young and being young has a lot of advantages that is you can enjoy a wide range of food and at the same time, you can enjoy a wide range of activies. I say go out and enjoy your youth.
 
Last edited:
You should be worrying about your BF% more than your weight to determine how much fat you're actually losing. Your weight changes throught the day and isn't an accurate measurement for the amount of fat that's actually on your body.
 
tjl:
I live in the South of France, where sidewalks/pavements are very rare. The drivers are crazy. It's impossible to bike/run anywhere near where I live, except for a park in my town -- which I have no means of getting to anyway. I walk when I can, however -- several times a week I'll walk home from school (20 minute walk). Otherwise, it's difficult to do any exercise outside, as the roads are very unsafe, being narrow and without sidewalk. I try to slot in as much exercise as possible.

And I don't know about my waist measurement -- my stomach/thighs simply feel much more "bloated" than they did before.

[Focus]:
Thank you for the advice.

I do go faster/harder on the stepper every night. Sometimes I'll use two 2kg weights at the same time.
 
I lost 4 kg in my first month by combining HIIT/weights with a caloric deficit diet. I was doing an hour of exercise daily. Half an hour of exercise doesn't cut it in my opinion. You can also do body-weight exercises if you are unable to find an affordable gym near you.
 
I'm a 17-year-old female (5'4"-5") and I weight 147lbs. I'm hoping to lose between 20 and 30 pounds in time for summer. At the end of October, I got myself one of those "mini stepper" machines, because I don't really have many other means of exercise where I live.

Congratulations on buying the mini stepper, and choosing a practical and reasonable goal for yourself, young lady! :).

You DO NOT need magical devices to lose fat tissue. The mini stair stepper and body weight exercises along with proper diet, can and will get the job you are seeking done; you will see the goal rainbow. In stead of a pot of goal at the end of the rainbow, it will have your shining and smiling face engraved in gold.

I have a maintenance line of about 2000+ calories or so, and I'm trying to keep my daily calore intake as 1,500.

MT Line= 2,000c
Calorie Deficit: -500c (1,500c intake)

How did you determine your MT Line of 2,000 calories? What formula did you use? What multiplyer did you use, etc.

The MT Line is supposed to be the calorie line that includes ALL ACTIVITES above your BMR (Base function calorie line), and this includes things such as work, training, etc.

When you say you "try to intake" 1,500c, what do you mean? So there is no misunderstanding on why I am asking this question, I will exapand a bit. When you are trying to intake 1,500c per day, are you tracking your calories and know for sure 1,500c is a VERY CLOSE approximation? Are you snacking or picking at foods you do not log within your calorie tracking? Small simple food items add up to 100c very quickly, and can take an additional hour to burn (example sitting at a pc desk burns approximately 120c per hour--dependent on the particulars of wgt, etc, of the person, and sleeping can burn 60 to 80 per hour). And, these little things can eat into the calories you burned in exercise and in turn makes your 1500c inaccurate, and thus your weight loss (or lack thereof) will show.


Every night, I do half an hour on the stepper, and according to its built-in calorie estimator, I burn about 250 calories per session. However, I have been doing this for about three months now, and not much has happened -- if anything, I feel much fatter. There have been days where I've skipped, or had a bit more to eat, but most of the time I'm reasonably good.

Approximate training expenditure: +/- 250c

Does this display allow you to input your age, wgt, hgt, and sex? If it does, this is more accurate than most, but I suspect still inaccurate (I dont trust them much). If it doesnt, than its even more inaccurate. Alot of calorie calculators on cardio machines, input averages, and not everyone is average.

NEVER EVER go 3 months again and allow no progress when seeking fat loss. Especially when one firsts starts out (assuming faithful to diet deficit), one should see tissue loss within 7 days with all things considered equal. ALWAYS critique fat loss at REGULAR intervals, and if fat loss ISNT occurring--something needs changing.

There are alot of things I do not know. At this time I know that you "skipped" or "had too much to eat"; however, I do not know the brevity of how much you had went over in calories or the amount of days (in 3 weeks) you skipped or ate too much. Dependent upon the aforementioned severity will depend how much of an impact it had on your goal. What I can say, I think quite safely, is that it did have an impact.

Lets consider things EQUAL for a moment: You determined your MT Line to be 2,000. You ate at 1,500c. You theoretically had a deficit of -500c per day. 5 times 7 is 3500 (there is approximately 3500 calories in one approximate pound of fat tissue). You should have lost about 1 pound per week IF YOU ATE STRICTLY AT 1500C per day--but YOU DIDNT. And your weight loss showed it.

If you are healthy, your calorie Vs. calorie expenditure is AMUCK--on one side or the other or both.

1. Tell me how you detemined your MT Line. Dependent on this information will depend on whether we need to adjust it.
2. Track your calories and what you eat PER DAY (some wont agree, but I am proof it can work)
3. Develop a program around your mini-stepper 3 to 4 times per week that INCLUDES a body weight exercise routine. Tony M (a mod) is a good one to give you examples.

If you track it. You have tools to change it; track it, change it and then battle it!

Its my opinion, that ALL bodily feed back IS GOOD, whether its positive feed back or negative feedback.

If its negative, than something is AMUCK, change something or you will more than likes get the same feedback. (This happened to you)

If its positive, than you know something is right, but be watchful and careful of the degrees. (We will try to get you here)

Same thing is APPLICABLE to the mind and mental attitude:

If its negative, than its going to destroying your goals, and something needs changing. (Have something in place to battle your food cravings that inhibit your goal pathway)

If its positive, than you know something is right, and be keenly aware of its degrees as well. seek knowledge to combat weakness and enhance strengths. One weakness you have right now, is that you allowed too much time to pass without changing something in your diet and routine. The body IS TELLING YOU that what you were doing wasnt the correct thing to do. Watch, look, and listen, to your body--it WILL tell you if you are doing the correct or incorrect things.

Being consciously aware of BOTH and having the ability to overcome them in the mind, is an essential successful element!

IF YOU WIN THE HIGHER PERCENTAGES of the battles in the head, you WILL overcome anything humanly possible.
==========================================================

Some additional thoughts:

Item 1. It's not necessarily what you eat but a function of "how much of what you eat" that matters the most.

Item 2. In addition, its more of a operation of calories IN (energy-how much of what you eat) vs. calories OUT(energy-body function, movement and activities), that is the basics of lowering body fat or gaining tissue weight.

Items 1 and 2 are fundelmentally critical to your success in lowering your body fat/losing weight.

Go here and read on some basic and fundamental information:

Weight Training 101

Mreik-per-your-request-nutritional ]Mreik per your request, Nutritional sticky

Weight Training Technical Articles

How to get abs guide

==========================================================

Item 3. Another essentional element in your weight loss/lowering body fat equation is "learning how to master the manipulation of calories (and macronutrients) vs. calories expended during various types of training/exercises."

This circumference of understanding will greatly assist item 4 (below). In addition, once you obtain a thorough understanding of your MT line, the deficits you are holding, and the amount of approximate calories expended during exercise, the variable tools available to you will give you a quality of vision few pursue to their personal goal advantage. Timing and application of this knowledge is a critical lever to have when problems develop--or even if you have a NEED to fill.


4. Additionally, its my opinion one needs to learn how to "master their self" within the confinement of the types of bodily feedback (psychological, biological, etc) that one WILL receive when deficit dieting or surplus dieting. It should be no surprise that if you deficit diet, that the body is going to kick in some psychological and biological defenses to compel you to eat. In addition, it should be no surprise that parts of ones personality (likes and dislikes, etc) can be a inhibitor. We can spend so much time on the basics on diet and fitness, and lose focus on one of the PRIMARY functions that can cause failure: Psychological and biological feed back of the body. Give TIME to gain knowledge on how to deal with them. Then learn how to apply what you have learned--you WILL NOT be sorry for the time or effort sacrificed.


Welcome to the forum. We do try to take the time to assist new and regular members. Sometimes its difficult because we dont know the level of knowledge of some that seek advice. I mean extremely well with this post. I wish you well in all that you do.

Ask as many questions as you deem necessary, and we will try to answer them.

Best regards and your friend,


Chillen
 
Last edited:
You just burned about 20 calories reading Chillen and now you need an aspirin...nice!:cool:

I got myself one of those "mini stepper" machines, because I don't really have many other means of exercise where I live. I burn about 250 calories per session.

Exercise is good, it not only helps burn calories, but also helps your mindset...it's psycholgoically tough to eat junk food after sweating hard.

Given that you're limited in space, I would strongly suggest getting some free-weights, elastic bands, a blow-up ball and other equipment so that you can incorporate some weight-training into your program...this will not only burn calories but also increase your metabolism. Get a good instruction video and get on it....it doesn't take much and the benefits are great.


I have been doing this for about three months now, and not much has happened -- if anything, I feel much fatter.

Don't be too hard on yourself. Once you're working-out & focused on the problem (weight/flab) it's typical to be more aware of your weight. I've lost about 50 pounds and there are days when I FEEL fatter then I did before I lost the weight. You're just more aware of it and are anxious for change. How are your clothes fitting? How you "feel" can be very misleading AND discouraging. If you're eating less and exercising more, I'm sure the change has occurred...stay on it!

I don't know why anything hasn't happened yet. Does anyone have any tips? I've also been told by a friend that when you first start exercising regularly, you will get heavier as muscle mass builds up. But when does the actual fat-burning start?

Once you place a toll on your muscles, your body will respond....muscle will build and very often the muscle gained can offset the fat lost in terms of what you see on the scale. I had several check-ups where my body-fat % went DOWN, yet my weight actually went UP. As suggested, focus on body-fat% and not so much the scale. It's ironic that the scale is the means by which we determine our dieting success, and equally ironic is that everyone will automatically ask you "so, how much weight have you lost?".....it's not about weight, it's about body-fat!

As for "when will actual body-fat burning start?".....it'll start the moment you create a calorie deficit where you have less calories coming in then going out. Don't think of it as a day by day event, more like week by week....it's a "big-picture" event horizon.

Focus on 1,500 calories per day, spend at least a couple weeks measuring and knowing how many calories you eat so you can guage in the future (when you no longer count, measure & weigh everything) how much you're eating. Calories have a criminal way of sneaking-up on ya...I thought I was at about 2,000 calories per day, but when I put it under the microscope I was consuming more like 2,750.....it adds-up and I can't stress enough how some small portions can have HUGE calories.

Be aware of what you eat...keep it light, healthy and whole. No more sugar, processed foods or nasty fats: lean meats, complex carbs, vege's and right choices. If you make rights choices, it's less important to count calories....but still, know what you're eating!

I myself feel ripped-off...it seems I have to work 5x harder then anyone else to lose weight. While others cut-out bread and do a bit of exercise and see results, I have to struggle & fight for each time ounce of loss.

You're weight took a while to get there, it's gonna take a while to get off. It's a long-haul process and it happens so slow you won't notice it happening! When I had lost 35 pounds I swore I looked & felt the same...until I saw a picture of myself and realized the difference.

Tips?....

Start your day with some low-carb yogurt, it's said to help burn abdominal fat and it's a good source of protein and a fine way to start your day.

Drink lots of non-carbonated, non-sweetened liquids. I like iced green-tea or that Vita-Rain stuff...try to avoid drinking calories

Stay away from gimmick Fat-Burners....it's all bs

Get a good education behind you, I really like "You on a Diet" by Doctor Oz...it's good reading and important to understand what's going on with your body!!

Make sure you understand food. We have an excellent resident nutritionist/trainer (Derwyddon) who has helped many people with their diet in many ways. Few forum members are aware of how helpful she's been behind the scenes! She's hot too!:luxlove::D

Try to exercise a little longer...
Try to eat a bit less (but not less then 1,250....you don't want your body to think you're starving)
Be patient, remain persistent and each day have a little bit of dark chocolate
 
tip for weight loss

Are you worrying about excess weight?You can so that you can reduce your body weight .Yoga is a system in order to keep body fit also.
 
Back
Top