My Weight Doesn't Drop, What should I do?

Steve said:
No, your experience is normal. It's the law of thermodynamics. You can neither create nor destroy energy. Calories are energy. If you are dieting, that means you MUST be in an energy deficit. Building muscle is a very intensive process, energetically speaking, meaning.... it requires a lot more energy above and beyond that which would maintain your current weight. You need to travel into the surplus range of energy balance in order to provide sufficient "fueling" of new muscle growth.

I have been wanting to gain muscle, and according to calorie calcs I need 2500 cal/day for muscle growth..but that number scares me because now I eat 1700. However 1700 is the amount I need for weight loss, while 2200 is my maintenance amount. I've NEVER eaten that much on a daily basis. I have to say, while on 1700 for 3 month I gained a LITTLE muscle, but I had also vastly changed my diet to include much more quality protein. In your opinon, if I am on the high end of the healthy BMI, would it be more beneficial to aim for fat loss or muscle growth? And if muscle growth- is it really necessary to eat 2500 cal/day?
Click to expand...
 
jk123 said:
Steve said:
No, your experience is normal. It's the law of thermodynamics. You can neither create nor destroy energy. Calories are energy. If you are dieting, that means you MUST be in an energy deficit. Building muscle is a very intensive process, energetically speaking, meaning.... it requires a lot more energy above and beyond that which would maintain your current weight. You need to travel into the surplus range of energy balance in order to provide sufficient "fueling" of new muscle growth.

I have been wanting to gain muscle, and according to calorie calcs I need 2500 cal/day for muscle growth..but that number scares me because now I eat 1700. However 1700 is the amount I need for weight loss, while 2200 is my maintenance amount. I've NEVER eaten that much on a daily basis. I have to say, while on 1700 for 3 month I gained a LITTLE muscle, but I had also vastly changed my diet to include much more quality protein. In your opinon, if I am on the high end of the healthy BMI, would it be more beneficial to aim for fat loss or muscle growth? And if muscle growth- is it really necessary to eat 2500 cal/day?
Click to expand...

I really suggest copying this question and pasting it in my journal. I'll reply to you there, so that we are not hijacking this thread that's already been beat up enough.
Click to expand...
 
Oh okay, sure. I didn't see a "journal" area, just the weight loss diaries- where is your journal? Thanks.
 
i am very confused about the whole strength training to lose fat controversy. Some say you can build muscle while losing fat, others say it's impossible. I have been strength training for about seven months now, and have lost 36lbs. My legs look very muscular, and while they have always been on the muscular side, they are more so now than they ever have been. Certainly when I weighed 90lbs less, they were not nearly as muscular as they are now. And I didn't gain the muscle in the 6yrs that it took me to put on the weight--I wasn't lifting any weights at all, and did very little exercise. If i had been, I wouldn't be as fat as I now am..lol

So I find it hard to believe that it's impossible or unlikely to gain muscle while losing weight. And when you have very reputable trainers and professionals saying that you CAN do both, I think I have to agree with them from my own personal experience.

Ok Steve, now you can trash my ideas...lol
 
Its not that losing fat and gaining muscle is impossible per se, so much as it is unlikely and very short-lived. There is a small window so to speak of time when a person who has been sedentary suddenly starts exercising and they can practically trick the body into creating some muscle while in a deficit. The strength training is realized much more quickly by the body as a stress and indicator for change than a reasonable deficit in calories is. So it might begin to make the adaptions for muscle and strength gain initially, but once the stress of caloric deficit kicks in, say goodbye to muscle gain.

There is also a bit of an issue with perspective here. Firstly, just because you appear more muscular after losing weight does NOT mean that you have actually gained muscle. You have simply lost the fat around the muscle which makes it more visible. It is a lesson in relativity. If there is less fat hiding the muscle it looks like there is more muscle overall, but there isnt neccesarily. My cousin looks like he is stronger and more muscular than me, but he weighs about 120 and has about 1/3 the lean body weight that i do. and yet he looks more muscular. Not to mention that his strength levels are about 1/4 of mine as well.

Strength is another issue people seem to confuse with muscle gain. Just because you have gotten stronger does not neccesarily mean that you have built more muscle. While the two are related, it is not a direct proportional relationship. You can increase strength without creating new muscle. From my understanding, alot of strength gain is a matter of improving neuromuscular efficiency and effectiveness. Which can be done while on a reasonable deficit, though generally more difficult.

A trainer who says you can increase muscle and lose fat at the same time is technically correct. If he says you can do it on a long term and substantial basis, he is full of shit. He/she is either ignorant, or knows how to play the mind games to keep himself making a living. Sadly, a fairly large portion of the health/fitness industry is pretty darn corrupt and/or ignorant.
 
I always have periods where I can't loose any weight. I talked to my doctor and she recommended a one week low carb diet when your weight won't drop anymore. She told me that its a good boost when your stuck.

I didn't read much of the thread, but I have to say that walking an hour a day has seriously boosted my metabolism. Before, I could look at something and gain ten pounds, but now I can totally pig out for a week and only gain a pound or two!
 
bikinibound said:
i am very confused about the whole strength training to lose fat controversy. Some say you can build muscle while losing fat, others say it's impossible. I have been strength training for about seven months now, and have lost 36lbs. My legs look very muscular, and while they have always been on the muscular side, they are more so now than they ever have been. Certainly when I weighed 90lbs less, they were not nearly as muscular as they are now. And I didn't gain the muscle in the 6yrs that it took me to put on the weight--I wasn't lifting any weights at all, and did very little exercise. If i had been, I wouldn't be as fat as I now am..lol

So I find it hard to believe that it's impossible or unlikely to gain muscle while losing weight. And when you have very reputable trainers and professionals saying that you CAN do both, I think I have to agree with them from my own personal experience.

Ok Steve, now you can trash my ideas...lol
Click to expand...

I'm not trashing your ideas at all.

And truthfully, we all have different experiences. If you've gained muscle and lost fat simultaneously for an appreciable length of time.... I believe ya. But that doesn't mean it's something that should be said to hundreds of people.

If you've experienced said circumstance, you would be considered a genetic elite/superior.

I've met many in my life. However, it's a very small percentage of the people I've worked with. 2-3% maybe.

For the genetic average and below, which makes up 98% of the world, they are governed by the laws of thermodynamics.

And that's that.

You pick a random sample of people and put them through the ropes of a high protein diet, caloric deficit, strength training, and maybe some cardio and they'll lose weight alright. A handful of them will even gain some muscle... but that will be short-lived. After a while their body will *figure out what's going on* and there won't be much more chance for muscle creation. That's not me spouting off my idea. It's what I see on a daily basis. It's what makes sense knowing what we know about the human body scientifically speaking.

So again, maybe you do lie within that upper echelon of people, genetically speaking. If so, lucky you!

I might add that the majority of people that claim impressive muscle gains while dieting over an appreciable length of time simply confuse muscle exposure for muscle gain.

You lose fat, you uncover muscle that's been there all along. It gives a very vivid picture of muscle gain, when in reality, you didn't. This could be what's going on too, unless you tracked the specific measurements required to say for fact, you gained muscle.

And one last point to add, it's been my experience from working with quite a few people that the fatter you are, the more likely you are to experience *good* body recomposition (lose fat, gain muscle simultaneously).

The closer you are to your set-point weight, the less likely.

ETA: I read coach's post after my own. He covered it well.
 
I highly doubt I'm in some "elite" genetic group..lol Perhaps it just looks to me like I am more muscular. I think my main concern was that we hear all the time that you should make sure to add strength training to your workouts when you're trying to lose weight. And then to hear people say that you cannot gain muscle while in a caloric deficiency, it's very contradictory. But now that I realize that the stregth training is important to maintain the muscle that one already has (so that we lose fat, not muscle), I feel less confused. Ok...I think I get it now. Thanks.:)
 
bikinibound said:
I highly doubt I'm in some "elite" genetic group..lol Perhaps it just looks to me like I am more muscular. I think my main concern was that we hear all the time that you should make sure to add strength training to your workouts when you're trying to lose weight. And then to hear people say that you cannot gain muscle while in a caloric deficiency, it's very contradictory. But now that I realize that the stregth training is important to maintain the muscle that one already has (so that we lose fat, not muscle), I feel less confused. Ok...I think I get it now. Thanks.:)
Click to expand...

Many people have problems differentiating between physique-improvement and muscle gain.

Or, they eat in a deficit one week and a surplus the next, thus netting out to some muscle gain and fat loss if things were done properly.

OR, they really did experience appreciable recomp and this usually means they're a genetic superior.
 
Diet AND exercise

All you need to do is burn more calories than you take in. Focus on burning the fat. Don't eat an hour before or after you work out. You need to burn stored fat, not fat that you have just eaten. Also, don't eat any complex carbs (rise, bread) after 3:00pm or so because it takes too long to burn off. You'll be sleeping most likely and won't be able to work it off =) Don't worry about what these other people are saying. They are getting to deep (especially Steve). We are here for support not to be belittled. Keep it up and be patient. You'll get there =) :flame:
 
Ya know, I really resent that. You bring up an old thread just to call me out for 'belittling' people. My apologies for enjoying discussion on an extremely relevant topic, considering what the subject of this board is. I also like the factual side of things, so it's always annoying to find someone such as yourself come in brushing off the facts as if they don't exist and then confusing people with bullshit simply b/c it has 'worked for you' with no understanding whatsoever.

Give personal experience... that's fine.

Don't try and bring down someone who actually does know his stuff simply b/c you aren't comfortable with the facts. That's not fair to the rest of the forum. Let your inadequacies rest with yourself.

Believe it or not, many here to enjoy learning... not just losing. But you wouldn't know that. You decided to open your mouth negatively on your second post without getting a feel for the forum at all.
 
Last edited:
We are here for support not to be belittled.
Click to expand...
This thread you pulled up almost a year old...
and this is your third post so let me clue you in to something.

If you want co-dependent style support where someone will hold your hand and tell you whatever ideas you might have, however misguided they might be- this forum probably isn't the right place for you -but Icould give you a list of about a two dozen or more that are like that... If y ou want to be educated... and go about losing weight, healthily, properly, and with long term results... then stick around...
 
Fat2Phat said:
Don't eat an hour before or after you work out. You need to burn stored fat, not fat that you have just eaten. Also, don't eat any complex carbs (rise, bread) after 3:00pm or so because it takes too long to burn off. You'll be sleeping most likely and won't be able to work it off =)
Click to expand...

this is about as much bad information as I've even seen condense into one paragraph. wow
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top