Multivitamin Standards in Different Countries?

I just made my first purchase at a supplement store today, the Mega Men Sport from GNC. I noticed that I live in Canada, and there is no product information on the GNC Canadian site, just on the American Site.

Why do I make a big deal about this? Well... there are different warning labels on each product. I do NOT have them mixed up.

Here is a picture of the box.

Here is a link to the American version:


It has the exact same product name, both contains 90 caplets, both time released.

So, the differences in warning labels are as follows.

Both version have the exact same statement about how its not for pregnant women, and not for people who require medication... all that stuff.

However, the Canadian package reads: This package contains enough Iron to seriously damage a child. There is 5mg of Iron in the Canadian version, and none in the American

The American version does NOT say this. The American package also says, that this product should be discontinued 2 weeks prior to surgery. Where as the Canadian Package does not say this.

There are different ingredients in both. The American one says it contains fish and soybeans, Canadian doesn't.

First ingredient on the Canadian label, is not stated on the American one, which is Beta Carotene, 10000IU per serving.

Then you get your vitamins...
Canadian:

A 2500IU
D 400IU
E 125IU
K1 80mcg
C 300mg
B1 50mg
B2 50mg

American:
A 5000IU (double)
D 200IU (half)
E 100IU (less)
K1 NONE <-- But there is 80mcg of K (not sure if its the same?)
C 300mg (same)
B1 NONE
B2 NONE

Anyways the list goes on... there are many many more ingredients, and the amounts in both hardly match up. And there are different vitamins in each supplement.

So, what does this mean?

I want to know, are there different levels of acceptance in the drug industry in each country?

Why is there Iron in mine, but not in the American version?

Why does it not warn me to discontinue 2 weeks prior to surgery? Does that mean I don't have to worry about that?

Why is there such a big difference? Its cheaper to research one formula, and have it mass produced, and shipped out, instead of researching more than one formula?

Which supplement is more effective or safer, or over all better to take?

Why not name them slightly different, or change the way the package is?

This is only a Multivitamin... what differences are there with the more serious muscle building formulas? Are there certain formulas that Canadians deem safe which the Americans do not? This scares me from some of those fat burners I was thinking about.
 
Multivitamins are not regulated by the FDA in the United States. Maybe that has something to do with it?

The Canadian version looks better. I heard too much A was bad for you anyway, and no B vitamins in the American version? BS!
 
well that was the first few on the list.

There is B-6 and B-12 in the American one. B-6 is the same, but there is 100mcg more in the Canadian one.
 
the advisories could be because the US is a very litigious society and manufacturers might feel the need to protect themselves from the idiocy that is the american consumer


( As I sit here and stare at my coffee cup which contains the warning label, the beverage i am about to consume is extremely hot - gee thanks I didn't know hot coffee was actually hot :)


Different countries might also have different reporting standards... it might well be the same formula but canada might have different standards.

I'd drop an email to GNC and ask...
 
I just find it intresting, because it is cheaper to just stick with one formula. So if Canada lets say had higher standards, then why not make just one formula and give it to America at Canadian standards, or vise versa. And so then how different is our crietien and wegh, fatburners.. ect from yours?
 
Last edited:
It might be cheaper to produce the US version of the vitamin which is why they have 2 formulas. It would be interesting to see the actual cost of each one in the same form of currency.
 
Back
Top