I eat plenty, but am still always hungry

BJJGinger

New member
I started my weight loss program two weeks ago, and have only lost maybe MAYBE 3 pounds (sometimes, too, if Ive eaten a lot of sodium, Ill be at my starting weight of 160 again). I weigh an average 157 in the mornings these days.
I walk 2 miles to the gym almost daily, do 35 minutes on the elliptical, 30 minutes lap swimming then walk 2 miles home. Im on Weight-Watchers, and try to stay as close to my points as possible, though I have a bad habit of fudging them a bit. I justify that by calculating out that I get an extra 5-8 points from exercise, on top of my daily 20-25 point range.
Im doing an mini-overhaul on my diet program though, because I find that Im not paying proper attention to servings, and am therefore very likely to be consuming more points than I write down.

Anyway, enough backstory, my problem is this: I am almost constantly hungry. Not cravings, just a nagging grumble in my stomach all day long. Like, this morning, I ate a breakfast of egg substitute (amount equivalent to two real eggs) with a fresh pear, but I wasnt satisfied. Half an hour later, I drank one of those protein/fiber drink mixes (South Beach- "Tide me Over") and Im STILL not satisfied. An hour or so later, I sat down and ate a frozen meal that was supposed to be high protein, and Im STILL hungry, even as Im typing this, almost uncomfortably hungry.

I know that cravings and hunger are different, and if youre hungry, you should eat because its not just your tongue telling you you want that cookie. I am actually hungry! I cant seem to eat enough to fill myself up, but I just feel like Im consuming so many calories, its really inhibiting my weight loss.

At which point, do I tell myself "Shut up, stomach! Youve had your food, now you need to bloody well stop complaining."

EDIT: I take a multivitamin daily, so I dont think a vitamin deficiency would be the cause.
 
Last edited:
I walk 2 miles to the gym almost daily, do 35 minutes on the elliptical, 30 minutes lap swimming then walk 2 miles home. Im on Weight-Watchers, and try to stay as close to my points as possible, though I have a bad habit of fudging them a bit. I justify that by calculating out that I get an extra 5-8 points from exercise, on top of my daily 20-25 point range.
Im doing an mini-overhaul on my diet program though, because I find that Im not paying proper attention to servings, and am therefore very likely to be consuming more points than I write down.

So you pay to be part of a weight loss plan that you cheat on? In my opinion, turn in your real numbers. How can they help you if you're "fudging" the numbers? As far as the hungry thing goes, how long has it been going on? I was hungry a lot for the first couple weeks. I got used to it in a month though. Now I couldn't stomach a big meal if you'd pay me to. Another thing that helps is to drink a lot of water. I usually do 2 gallons a day.
 
Maybe you aren't eating enough like you think you are. Do you write everything down in a food journal.. And do you know how many calories for sure your body needs a day. If not.. start there. Then If your getting all the calories maybe you should eat more, but healthy choices.. And your pretty active so that might need that you will need more because your burning more..
 
Well, Bmac, no, Im not actually paying to be on it. My mother was on it a few years ago, and she saved all the material and is now lending it to me. So, Im on bootleg Weight Watchers, I guess. No meetings, no weigh-ins, no fee. Just me, and all their pamphlets and geegaws.
I just started really noticing the hunger maybe a week ago. I eat when Im bored, and not really hungry (my absolute worst vice),, so when I realized that I actually WAS hungry all the time, it was a little shocking.

LeaJnice; if anything, Im eating more than I need to. I mean, Im known for doubling the serving size but only jotting down the points for a single serving. Ive caught myself doing that on numerous occassions, and am trying to work on it. I do keep a food journal, rather religiously. I keep two sides, one for food and one for exercise, with the date and my weight at the top, each day. But no, Ive never actually sat down and calculated the real caloric numbers that I need. Maybe I should do that, and see where Im standing...
 
Well, Bmac, no, Im not actually paying to be on it. My mother was on it a few years ago, and she saved all the material and is now lending it to me. So, Im on bootleg Weight Watchers, I guess. No meetings, no weigh-ins, no fee. Just me, and all their pamphlets and geegaws.
I just started really noticing the hunger maybe a week ago. I eat when Im bored, and not really hungry (my absolute worst vice),, so when I realized that I actually WAS hungry all the time, it was a little shocking.

LeaJnice; if anything, Im eating more than I need to. I mean, Im known for doubling the serving size but only jotting down the points for a single serving. Ive caught myself doing that on numerous occassions, and am trying to work on it. I do keep a food journal, rather religiously. I keep two sides, one for food and one for exercise, with the date and my weight at the top, each day. But no, Ive never actually sat down and calculated the real caloric numbers that I need. Maybe I should do that, and see where Im standing...

Ah, ok :D Bootleg WW's... haha I like that. Lea's suggestion is a good start. I've lost 65pounds man, when I first started I was hungry a lot. Just kept eating 5-6 small meals/snacks a day. Usually hitting the 1800-2200 mark on calories. Like I said, hungry a lot at the start but it went away after a few weeks. Your stomach shrinks and expands, once it shrinks again with smaller portions, it'll be easier to get full. Like I said before as well, drink a lot of water. Our bodies sometimes give us symptoms similar to hunger when we're dehydrated.
 
Maybe try to find foods with more whole grains in them, they take more time to digest, release sugars in to your bloodsteam slower and generally keep you satiated longer. Try a bowl of oatmeal in the morning instead of just eggs and fruit. Drink more water or hot tea even, I find that a nice hot cup of tea will stop my grumbly belly quick. In fact, I'm using that trick right now.
 
Well, Bmac, no, Im not actually paying to be on it. My mother was on it a few years ago, and she saved all the material and is now lending it to me. So, Im on bootleg Weight Watchers, I guess. No meetings, no weigh-ins, no fee. Just me, and all their pamphlets and geegaws.

wow, that's exactly what i did a few years ago. that was the most successful diet i've ever done (20lbs. lost)! and i got everything from my mom who used to be on it! weight watchers worked for me, but i've heard that it doesn't for a lot of people. if it isn't working out, i would recommend trying other diets to see what works.(Jenny Craig, South Beach Diet, Nutrisystem, ect.) hope i helped!
 
Speaking of feeling hungry all the time,I have this weird thing....on the weekends, I COULD go all day without eating, I don't, of course, but I could. I just don't feel hungry then. And when I'm upset or nervous, which is often lately, I simply CAN'T eat. But, Monday through Friday, while I'm at work, I feel STARVED. Not just a simple little craving, mind you, but the real "growling-stomach-hunger-pains-I'm-gonna-throw-up-if-I-don't-eat-something-right-now"
feeling. So, I eat something. Sometimes it's fruit or veggie or popcorn, sometimes its cake or cookies or brownies or chocolate. Then, I have the same feeling a few hours later!!! By the time I get home from work, I feel like a bloated pig! I do sip water throughout the day, and that doesn't seem to help. Anyone know what causes this weird syndrome?
 
Jedi, I would say that is because on weekdays you wake up early, and start your day with something to eat...right? You wake your metabolism up bright and early and get it running for the day. Where as on the weekend you sleep in, probably lollygag about and don't necessarily eat breakfast right away...am I correct?
 
Well, Cherry, I lost 5 lbs on WW last year, and really liked it! I think its easy, it makes sense, and I like that it doesnt restrict you to certain foods.
I tried South Beach, but two days into phase 1, I got sick of all the food I was actually allowed to eat and so, just wouldnt eat. I lived on pistachios and string cheese, reluctant to even eat those foods, but knowing I had to eat something, for a week before I realized that it was terrible for me, it was making me sick and utterly miserable, and I said " screw that!" and havent looked back.
 
Read up on the glycemic index. The foods that are better for you according to the GI will keep you satiated longer. For example, brown rice will keep you full longer than the same amount of instant white rice.
 
While you are losing weight - stop looking at hunger like it's the anti-christ. What's so hard about being a little hungry for awhile? We put up with so many discomforts in life because we have to. I'm not saying it's easy to be hungry - it's not - it sucks - but start thinking about it for what it is - a short term symptom of a long-term goal. I like to think about a little feeling of hunger as my body eating away at that extra fat :) Pretty sure that's not scientific or anything - but the image makes me feel great!
 
I seem to be lucky, the first 5 days or so I was starving, then its kind of evened out. I get hungry every so often, but nothing like before. Coupled with the cravings its was bad. I also think its my state of mind now too. i try to drink lots of water. Drinking water to keep fill is a bit of a myth, BUT when dehydrated you DO get similiar triggers as when hungry so its awlays best to not get there.

To the person who mentioned getting hungry at work, its the slump syndrome. Its the same reason why you feel dead tired and just can't wait toget home and goto sleep, but when you get home you feel energized and fine. Its tough, especially for those of us on night shift, but its one of those things you just have to power through.
 
I seem to be lucky, the first 5 days or so I was starving, then its kind of evened out.

I've had the same experience. I think it's one reason it's so hard to cut back at first. The hunger seems unbearable - but when you keep it up for a few days your body adapts and you start to wonder why it was such a big deal. It really does help to spread out what you eat throughout the day instead of doing 3 larger meals. Of course, the ideal situation is to get your body to a healthy weight and go on to maintenance. But seriously, you still want to get hungry before you eat! Food tastes much better when you're hungry.
 
I'm going to throw my 2 cents in here even though most of it has been covered.

Our minds have a big issues with telling the difference between being thirsty and being hungry. I carry around a 3 liter bottle of water all day. And when the grumbles start, out comes my little glass. If after a glass I'm still grumbling, then I start with something small to snack. I've found some really good "treats" that are low cal but satisfy me like a helping of laughing cow low fat cheese (the waxed portions are 70 calories, the tinned portions are 35 calories). They taste "sinful", but aren't. I, personally, don't recommend a "diet" because once you've reached your goal weight...you don't know how to eat like a normal person. So, you revert to your old ways...old ways made you fat. Guess where you'll be 6 months down the line? Pull out a piece of paper and start marking down how many calories you're actually taking in per day. I carry around veggies that I'm not a real big fan of (celery, for example). It's either make it through the day until it's time for my next meal...or it's celery. If I munch on a few sticks...one of two things happens. Either my hunger decides it ain't worth the celery, lol, or I become "full". Either way, 30 calories in celery shuts my stomach up for a long time. Probably because my brain says, "If you start telling her that we're hungry, we're getting more celery...so shut up!". I also agree that foods that will stick with you for quite some time will be a better choice than others. Certainly don't give in to raiding the vending machines because you're hungry. Bring food with you even if you don't expect to be hungry. Maybe you'll eat it, maybe you won't. Sometimes our bodies tell us to eat because we're stressed or bored. Chances are good that during a time that you're brain is 100% focused on something...your body won't be screaming "food time!". So find something to occupy your mind, as well. Good luck!
 
How about fiber intake? Are you consuming a good amount (25-35 grams per day)?

Fiber will expand your stomach and give you that full feeling often like protein can. Check you whole grains and consume dark leafy green veggies and berries for added fiber in your food choices.

On a side note, I noticed in your exercise program you weren't performing and weight training. Is there a reason for that? A solid weight training program will go a long way toward acclerating your fat loss efforts.
 
If Weight Watchers doesn't work out for you, may I recommend calorie counting? That's all weight watchers is; the points system is just an abstract form of calorie counting, and then with meetings and books and such thrown in.

It just seems to me that it'd be harder to let yourself get away with counting two servings as one with calorie counting.
 
Back
Top