Weight Loss vs. Fat Loss

This may or may not apply to anyone in this forum but this has been bothering me for a long time...

There is a huge misconception among girls/women about the whole idea of losing weight... losing weight and losing fat are two different things, and women are so caught up with losing weight that they'll do anything... when the real issue is not the weight that's being lost, but rather the fat.

Weight comes from several places:
1) Muscle Mass... which is typically the largest contributor to weight
2) Bone... some people are big or small-boned, so everyone's different
3) Fat... which is really what everyone's concerned about, they just confuse fat with weight.

My ex-girlfriend used to be so excited when she found out she had lost a pound or two... when in reality she hadn't exercised in a month and looked basically the same as she always had. She had most likely lost muscle mass, and had hurt metabolism in the process, so calories are less easily burned by her body and more quickly stored as fat... exactly what she didn't want.

A lot of this misconception comes from the ease with which we can measure weight, but the comparative difficulty and inaccuracy of body fat measurements. There are increasingly cheap and accurate body fat scales now, such as Tanita scales, but most people still rely on the brute method of weighing yourself as a gauge of overall fitness. This is simply ridiculous and leads to a lot of unhealthy behaviors to try to lose weight.

Please help spread the word among your friends... what's really important is not the weight you've lost, but rather the fat you've burned. The more people that know, the less we'll see girls starving themselves to try to reach a certain weight. Thanks for your help.

Aaron Smyth
GymTicket Support
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think this misconception applies singularly to women. Furthermore, people who starve themselves have deeper psychological issues than not understanding the relationship between weight loss, fat loss, and overall fitness.
 
You're absolutely right... the misconception applies to just about everyone in our culture. I say women because guys don't typically go to such extreme measures to make a certain weight, so this problem most noticeably affects them. I'm just trying to get the word out there.

Aaron Smyth
GymTicket Support
 
Last edited by a moderator:
One other factor in weight you missed, which most contributes to small variations in body weight over short periods of time is WATER. You can "loose" or "gain" 10+ pounds of water over the course of a day or 2 if you sweat a lot and don't replace the lost fluids, or it is your "time of the month" and you retain extra water or...
 
My ex-girlfriend used to be so excited when she found out she had lost a pound or two... when in reality she hadn't exercised in a month and looked basically the same as she always had. She had most likely lost muscle mass, and had hurt metabolism in the process, so calories are less easily burned by her body and more quickly stored as fat... exactly what she didn't want.

Aaron Smyth
GymTicket Support

Going a month without working out is not long enough to loose muscle mass equal to a pound or two.
 
One other factor in weight you missed, which most contributes to small variations in body weight over short periods of time is WATER. You can "loose" or "gain" 10+ pounds of water over the course of a day or 2 if you sweat a lot and don't replace the lost fluids, or it is your "time of the month" and you retain extra water or...

So true about water weight. I don't get that "time of the month thing" but I do drink like a fish and my weight fluctuates throughout the day. Best to weigh yourself in the morning.

Silent - You can't lose a pound of muscle in a month? Even through excessive low calories?

~Nicole
 
Silent - You can't lose a pound of muscle in a month? Even through excessive low calories?
~Nicole

If you are eating right and are doing daily activities i doubt (unless a medical condition is present that might speed the process) Going a month will not have a dramatic affect on ones muscle mass.

Of course their are many factors that play here. But in general, the average person who ate right, and did do some physical labor just from daily activity's. Loosing such a large amount of muscle mass ,in such a short time frame, shouldn't be much of a concern.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top