Will this plan work? (It's not the typical diet + exercise)

coyote1

New member
Hey all. It's really inspirational and supportive to read your posts each day - keeps me motivated and reminds me to 'stay good' haha. Anyway, I noticed almost everyone has a specific plan, i.e. eating a certain amount of calories or restricting which foods are eaten and exercising regularly. However, I'm not planning to do that.

Trying to keep this brief: I was overweight/obese since around age 9, and it wasn't until I was 16, 5'4 and 214 lbs that I realized I had a problem. I vowed to get down to a healthy weight. After 2 years of a vegan diet and gym trips, I was down to about 175 lbs. I weight to college then at age 18 and without thinking about it, began to eat healthier. I usually ate alone and the cafeteria's vegan choices were limited, so each meal was small and quick. By the end of 2007 (after my first semester there), I weighed 159 lbs. I was so excited! I had no idea that I had been losing weight. Of course, like so many weight loss stories, there was a turning point. I became vegetarian again instead of vegan, I stopped exercising, and started eating all the time. I knew I was gaining weight but I ignored it and thought it'd go away on its own. Didn't happen, and I had a very rude wake-up call in May 2010 when I was weighed at a doctor's office - I was right back at 214 lbs. I was annoyed because I had been so close to a healthy weight and I completely ruined my efforts and put myself back on square 1. Not only that, but I was spending the summer abroad in China and I felt like I was going to be a terrible representation of my country. Well, after 2 months I lost 25 pounds through eating less and walking everywhere. Again, I had no idea that I was losing weight. When I got home, I had a very hard time adjusting to American food. I found myself disgusted actually. I was restless and constantly wanted to walk or do something else physical. It all came together and made me realize something.

To me, weight loss isn't about what you eat or what you do. It's not supposed to be something you think about. Think of all the skinny people out there that eat crap and never move and still look great. I know it's a simple equation of calories in vs. calories out, but again, do naturally skinny people count calories? Nope. They don't have to. I finally realized my problem was compulsive eating - eating when I wasn't hungry. I read a couple books on the subject that all said the same thing: some people lose their natural instinct to stop eating when they're full. I definitely did. Realizing this in combination with my new weight loss gave me determination to change things once and for all.

I don't weigh myself very often (maybe 4 times a year) and I don't plan on changing that. I'm done trying to count calories and I'm done restricting my food choices (though I'll always remain a vegetarian). I'm not holding myself to strict exercise either. I'm simply going to live like everyone else was intended to - eating only when I'm hungry and stopping when I'm not.

I walk between 60-90 minutes every day and I eat only when I feel hunger. I've been doing this for 2 months now. I last weighed in in August (about 180 lbs), and as much as I want conformation that I'm losing weight because I can't see a difference, I've never been able to see myself losing weight in the past, so I don't think I'm touching the scale til the end of the year.

So, from those experienced in losing weight, will my simple strategy of no-scale, no-diet, no-gym work as long as I remain somewhat active and maintain a healthy caloric intake? Most importantly, can I trust my body to tell me what a healthy caloric intake is - i.e. when I'm hungry, I actually need more calories?

Thanks to everyone who takes the time to read this and respond. Sorry if this is longer than it should be, or if I should post this somewhere else.
 
Hey Coyote! I think you've got the right idea. I think as long as you are active and eat healthy you should be fine. One thing to remember: I wouldn't necessarily advocate being naturally skinny. Some of those so-called skinny ppl are also called skinny fat. In other words, they might be petite but aren't really fit or aren't really healthy on the inside. So just keep that in your mind I would say to motivate yourself to keep the weight off in a "better for you" kind of way if that makes sense. Hope that helps! =)
 
Yeah, I don't count calories and never have during my whole diet.

You can get too into the whole thing. You just need to have some basic food intelligence. Having a chocolate bar or having an apple? It's pretty easy. You can over complicate a diet to some extent.

The only thing I would change is that you NEED to weigh yourself weekly. Otherwise how do you know if it's working? Maybe you lost 3lbs last week and that's amazing, but you'll never know because you didn't weigh yourself.

Or on the flip side, maybe you think it's OK to eat chocolate for breakfast and you think it's fine to drink loads of beers everyday. "Hey as long as I go for a walk, it'll be OK, RIGHT?" And you think you are losing weight, but you aren't and you'd never know because you don't weigh yourself. Obviously this is an extreme example :D

It's not sensible to weigh yourself EVERYDAY for example as your body can fluctuate quite alot. But I do suggest weekly. Yeah, you might not see any results week to week, but after a month? Certainly you should; else you know the diet isn't working and you can make changes. If you wait 6 months and find out you weigh 2lbs less or something stupid, will you feel good? Probably not.
 
I'd love to weigh myself more, at least more than 4 times a year haha, but I don't own a scale or have access to one. I just wait for the opportunity to present itself (i.e. a surprise bathroom scale in a Shanghai hotel). I'm just afraid I would become obsessed with it and start weighing myself constantly, even at a healthy weight. I'm really wary of it because my best friend developed anorexia a few years ago and it started after she began constantly checking her weight. She's recovered now thankfully but she told me she doesn't ever weigh herself now because as long as she looks good, there's no point obsessing over a number.

Thankfully I have decent eating habits finally, after almost 6 years of vegetarianism, having plenty of nutritionist friends, reading a fair amount of literature on the subject, and having completely lost my appetite for most Western foods. I tried kidding myself a few years ago that I 'got it' but now it feels good to really understand how food should work - as a fuel source to keep you alive, not something to gorge upon.

I will take your advice and try to find a scale I can use to weigh myself - even if it means going to Walmart and using one there every week LOL.
 
Just buy a set of scales. They aren't exactly expensive.

Just weigh yourself at with the same scales, every week in the same place at a similar time of day and you'll be fine.

Using different scales is basically useless. Believe me.
 
i know what your saying about naturaly skinny people and only eating when your hungry, i`m forever having somthing to eat (some cereal, salad sandwich) when i feel the slightest bit hungry or that twinge in your stomach that just feels so empty. i have that feeling right now but instead of running to the kitchen i`m egnoreing it, i`m pretty sure skinny people live with that feeling as i was once skinny myself and have the stretch marks to prove it.

btw tea is a great substitute for food, english have been useing it for years.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top