question

ak19820

New member
ive been researching about weight loss for the past week and i still can't figure out my best solution.

i'm 17. 5'2. weight 126 lbs. have practice every single day for a sport.
i have really bad eating habits and eat fattening food. so obviously i should stop on that. i was reading somewhere where it said if you eat too much you stretch your stomach. so i want to shrink my stomach. i dont want to do all these crazy weight loss things that people are talking about. i just wanna loose some belly fat by the beginning of june. roughly i want to loose around 10(being the minimum) to 15(being the maximum) lbs.

i want to stay healthy. so i dont want to starve myself. i dont mind taking any pills. just not crazy ones that ive been reading about that can give you gallstones.

i dont want to count my calories. been there, and done that before. its too much effort and i dont have the time for that.

drink a lot of water and eat fiber and protien ive read. is that true?

when i go to the gym (once a week) i run a mile. work on abs yada yada all that stuff. but nothing seems to work. ive maintained this weight for forever.

so im pretty sure my bad eating habits are wearing me down. any suggestions? i would love the advice.
 
ive been researching about weight loss for the past week and i still can't figure out my best solution.

i'm 17. 5'2. weight 126 lbs. have practice every single day for a sport.
i have really bad eating habits and eat fattening food. so obviously i should stop on that. i was reading somewhere where it said if you eat too much you stretch your stomach. so i want to shrink my stomach. i dont want to do all these crazy weight loss things that people are talking about. i just wanna loose some belly fat by the beginning of june. roughly i want to loose around 10(being the minimum) to 15(being the maximum) lbs.

i want to stay healthy. so i dont want to starve myself. i dont mind taking any pills. just not crazy ones that ive been reading about that can give you gallstones.

i dont want to count my calories. been there, and done that before. its too much effort and i dont have the time for that.

drink a lot of water and eat fiber and protien ive read. is that true?

when i go to the gym (once a week) i run a mile. work on abs yada yada all that stuff. but nothing seems to work. ive maintained this weight for forever.

so im pretty sure my bad eating habits are wearing me down. any suggestions? i would love the advice.

Why is counting calories too much effort? How don't you have the time for it?

I don't know if you are male or female but your estimated BMR is 1400 - 1500 depending on your gender. That means you need to be eating under that amount (or exercising enough to get you under that total by the end of the day) in order to lose weight. You obviously need to be keeping some track of calories to know where you are though.

Yes, you need to stop eating fatty foods like you said. Eating fatty foods is only stopping your progress all together. You have good potential to lose 1.2lbs a week safely.

You can't really "spot reduce". This means that working your abs by doing sit ups or crunches will not make you burn fat in your belly, it will just make muscle there. Cardio allows you to burn fat all over (including your belly).

Stay away from trans fats as it seems to be one of the contributors to belly bulge.

I (and many others here) would not recommend you taking weight loss pills. Not only are they basically gimmicks, they also teach you nothing about how to stick to a healthy weight. So once you're off the pills the weight comes back.

Develop healthy habits.
 
Why is counting calories too much effort? How don't you have the time for it?

I don't know if you are male or female but your estimated BMR is 1400 - 1500 depending on your gender. That means you need to be eating under that amount (or exercising enough to get you under that total by the end of the day) in order to lose weight. You obviously need to be keeping some track of calories to know where you are though.

Yes, you need to stop eating fatty foods like you said. Eating fatty foods is only stopping your progress all together. You have good potential to lose 1.2lbs a week safely.

You can't really "spot reduce". This means that working your abs by doing sit ups or crunches will not make you burn fat in your belly, it will just make muscle there. Cardio allows you to burn fat all over (including your belly).

Stay away from trans fats as it seems to be one of the contributors to belly bulge.

I (and many others here) would not recommend you taking weight loss pills. Not only are they basically gimmicks, they also teach you nothing about how to stick to a healthy weight. So once you're off the pills the weight comes back.

Develop healthy habits.


im a girl. sorry, one thing i forgot. haha. but should i eat breakfast lunch and dinner and no snacks or only eat 2 big meals a day? and cardio is the only way to burn bellyfat is what you are saying?
 
Why is counting calories too much effort? How don't you have the time for it?

I don't know if you are male or female but your estimated BMR is 1400 - 1500 depending on your gender. That means you need to be eating under that amount (or exercising enough to get you under that total by the end of the day) in order to lose weight. You obviously need to be keeping some track of calories to know where you are though.

Yes, you need to stop eating fatty foods like you said. Eating fatty foods is only stopping your progress all together. You have good potential to lose 1.2lbs a week safely.

You can't really "spot reduce". This means that working your abs by doing sit ups or crunches will not make you burn fat in your belly, it will just make muscle there. Cardio allows you to burn fat all over (including your belly).

Stay away from trans fats as it seems to be one of the contributors to belly bulge.

I (and many others here) would not recommend you taking weight loss pills. Not only are they basically gimmicks, they also teach you nothing about how to stick to a healthy weight. So once you're off the pills the weight comes back.

Develop healthy habits.


oh and i dont want to count calories because i feel like it's too much effort to find out exactly how many calories are in every single thing you eat. when you go out to eat or school lunches they don't tell you how many calories are in everything. not everything is labeled on the side so its hard to keep up with. i feel like it would be so much work and effort
 
im a girl. sorry, one thing i forgot. haha. but should i eat breakfast lunch and dinner and no snacks or only eat 2 big meals a day? and cardio is the only way to burn bellyfat is what you are saying?

Yes. Cardio (any aerobic exercise) burns fat all over the body including your belly.
Don't give in to scams and gimmicks that say "drink this" or "eat this" to lose weight here or there.

As far as your meals are concerned... everyone seems to have their own routine that works for them. I personally eat man times a day. That just works for me. Some others eat the traditional 3 times a day. Others eat somewhere between. It's based on your lifestyle and what works best for you or what makes you feel the best. There are studies on 'eating frequently' but people seem to realize which option is the best for them without any problem. There is no one-size fits all strategy.

Here is a link from WebMD about whether it's best to take in 6 meals or 3 meals a day.
6 vs 3 meals a day
 
I'd like to answer that question. I believe that when your eating every 2-3 hrs that it keeps your metabolism running longer than if you were to eat once every 4-5 hrs. So in short, eat smaller, more frequent meals.

As far as burning bellyfat, Emerald was right, you can't spot reduce. You're gonna have to work it off with cardio. Thats not to say that sit ups dont' have their place, but thats more for building muscle than burning fat.
 
WebMD 6 vs 3 Meals per day

March 31, 2011--Eating small meals frequently throughout the day may not help take the bite out of your hunger while you are dieting, according to a new study.

Many diets and dietitians promote such mini meals, but they may not be any better than three square meals a day when it comes to feeling full and satisfied, according to a new study in Obesity.

“You hear a lot in the lay press claiming that mini meals were better, but there was no scientific evidence to support these claims,” says study researcher Heather J. Leidy, PhD, an assistant professor of nutrition and exercise physiology at the University of Missouri in Columbia. Leidy was getting her PhD at Purdue University in West Lafayette, Ind., when the study was conducted. “We are not saying three meals a day is the best, but mini meals are not any more beneficial at controlling appetite,” she says.

3 Meals vs. 6

Twenty-seven overweight or obese men were placed on a reduced-calorie diet in which either 25% or 14% of the calories came from lean protein for 12 weeks. Men were asked to eat the same diet as three meals or six meals a day for three days starting at week seven, and then they switched to the other eating pattern for three more days.

Men recorded their feelings of hunger or satiety every hour that they were awake during the three- or six-meal-a-day portion of the study using an electronic device.

Men who ate low-calorie, high-protein diets felt more satisfied and less hungry than those eating a low-calorie, normal protein diet, the new study showed.

Those men who ate six mini meals a day showed no improvement in appetite control or perceived fullness compared to those who ate three meals a day.

The findings are likely applicable to overweight or obese women, Leidy says. Some people such as athletes, recreational runners, and people with diabetes or prediabetes, however, may benefit from eating smaller meals more frequently throughout the day, she says.

“But eating more frequently is not the best diet strategy to combat obesity
,” she says.

No One-Size-Fits All Strategy

This is a tricky one, says Dana Greene, MS, RD, a nutritionist in Brookline, Mass. “Some people enjoy eating small meals throughout the day, and others don't have the time and/or don't care to eat so frequently,” she says.

The three meals in this study were calorie controlled, which is what helps weight loss, Greene says.

“It was thought that eating small meals more frequently helps stabilize blood sugar and better controls appetite, but if those frequent meals aren't appropriately portioned, this won't work,” she says. “I don't think there is a one-size-fits-all answer.”

Unrealistic Expectations

Tanya Zuckerbrot, RD, author of The F-Factor Diet and a New York City-based nutritionist, says that "a diet consisting of six meals throughout the day can be unrealistic to maintain considering people’s hectic lifestyles.”

In an email, she says that “when you eat a more substantial meal, you get increased sensory stimulation because you have more food going through your mouth and you’re eating for a longer period of time, both of which help to promote feelings of satisfaction.”

Zuckerbrot promotes a combination of lean protein and fiber at every meal. “Meals consisting of a combination of fiber and protein will help keep you feeling full longer because they take the longest time to digest,” she says. “They also keep blood sugar levels stabilized and thus prevent drastic spikes and crashes in sugar levels that can ultimately lead to increased hunger, bingeing, and/or making poor choices at mealtimes.”

The National Pork Board and the American Egg Board funded the new study. Eggs and lean pork were among the main sources of protein in the diets.
 
WebMD 6 vs 3 Meals per day

March 31, 2011--Eating small meals frequently throughout the day may not help take the bite out of your hunger while you are dieting, according to a new study.

Many diets and dietitians promote such mini meals, but they may not be any better than three square meals a day when it comes to feeling full and satisfied, according to a new study in Obesity.

“You hear a lot in the lay press claiming that mini meals were better, but there was no scientific evidence to support these claims,” says study researcher Heather J. Leidy, PhD, an assistant professor of nutrition and exercise physiology at the University of Missouri in Columbia. Leidy was getting her PhD at Purdue University in West Lafayette, Ind., when the study was conducted. “We are not saying three meals a day is the best, but mini meals are not any more beneficial at controlling appetite,” she says.

3 Meals vs. 6

Twenty-seven overweight or obese men were placed on a reduced-calorie diet in which either 25% or 14% of the calories came from lean protein for 12 weeks. Men were asked to eat the same diet as three meals or six meals a day for three days starting at week seven, and then they switched to the other eating pattern for three more days.

Men recorded their feelings of hunger or satiety every hour that they were awake during the three- or six-meal-a-day portion of the study using an electronic device.

Men who ate low-calorie, high-protein diets felt more satisfied and less hungry than those eating a low-calorie, normal protein diet, the new study showed.

Those men who ate six mini meals a day showed no improvement in appetite control or perceived fullness compared to those who ate three meals a day.

The findings are likely applicable to overweight or obese women, Leidy says. Some people such as athletes, recreational runners, and people with diabetes or prediabetes, however, may benefit from eating smaller meals more frequently throughout the day, she says.

“But eating more frequently is not the best diet strategy to combat obesity
,” she says.

No One-Size-Fits All Strategy

This is a tricky one, says Dana Greene, MS, RD, a nutritionist in Brookline, Mass. “Some people enjoy eating small meals throughout the day, and others don't have the time and/or don't care to eat so frequently,” she says.

The three meals in this study were calorie controlled, which is what helps weight loss, Greene says.

“It was thought that eating small meals more frequently helps stabilize blood sugar and better controls appetite, but if those frequent meals aren't appropriately portioned, this won't work,” she says. “I don't think there is a one-size-fits-all answer.”

Unrealistic Expectations

Tanya Zuckerbrot, RD, author of The F-Factor Diet and a New York City-based nutritionist, says that "a diet consisting of six meals throughout the day can be unrealistic to maintain considering people’s hectic lifestyles.”

In an email, she says that “when you eat a more substantial meal, you get increased sensory stimulation because you have more food going through your mouth and you’re eating for a longer period of time, both of which help to promote feelings of satisfaction.”

Zuckerbrot promotes a combination of lean protein and fiber at every meal. “Meals consisting of a combination of fiber and protein will help keep you feeling full longer because they take the longest time to digest,” she says. “They also keep blood sugar levels stabilized and thus prevent drastic spikes and crashes in sugar levels that can ultimately lead to increased hunger, bingeing, and/or making poor choices at mealtimes.”

The National Pork Board and the American Egg Board funded the new study. Eggs and lean pork were among the main sources of protein in the diets.

thank you! that was very helpful
 
I believe that when your eating every 2-3 hrs that it keeps your metabolism running longer than if you were to eat once every 4-5 hrs.

Sorry Korrie, This is not true. Even steve has a long unreadable thread contradicting this tip. I Just read it this morning. Perhaps you can explore it further if you don't believe me Korrie. Do some deeper research about metabolism.

Overnight your metabolism slows down but it won't slow down if you go without eating for 4-5 hours. Its is usually recommended that you eat breakfast because that kick starts your metabolism again but it will keep going all day at a normal rate.

I always thought the reasoning behind eating more than three meals a day was to help you get through those periods between meals when you might get hungry.

I personally recommend eating 3 meals a day and if you find you are peckish between meals, eat a piece of fruit or something low in calories. But i can't see the necessity of scheduling in a snack otherwise you will eat even when you are not hungry.

If you get really hungry between meals, eat a salad sandwich or something similar. The salad will fill you up without adding a lot of calories as long as you keep the butter thinly spread and don't sneak in other fat into your sandwhich. Make it with wholemeal, rye or multigrian bread because this type of bread has more nutrients and will keep you satisfied for longer than white bread.

But definitely give away all that high fat food. Just quit it.
 
I think i was posting at the same time as emerald.

Anyhow, i wanted to add something else that i think might be important for ak.

I don't count calories either but i have learnt what are high calorie foods and what are low calorie foods. YOu do probably need to make some effort to understand nutrition if you are going to be successful in the long term at managing your weight and shape. Get a book out of the library. Ask one of the librarians to recommend something reputable as there are many diet gurus who advocate rather false ideas.

According to my info book you are within the healthy weight range though you can lose a lot more weight without harming your health. You can go as low as 112 pounds according to this book. Its based on your height. Once you go below that weight your BMI will get in the low range where doctors might start to diagnose you as anorexic, particularly if you held that weight for a long time and had difficulty putting it on again. Anyway don't go there. Its not worth it.

Yes drink about 8 glasses of water a day. As you are so small i hardly can see the need to drink more than that. The water can be any other liquid form but not tea or coffee as these are dehydrating. But i don't recommend drinking a lot of fruit juice either. I won't detail that. Just don't do it.

Fibre is good. Its in your vegetables, fruit, some unprocessed cereals and grains. You don't need fibre pills.

We all need protein. Its job is to mend tissues and build muscles and such things. I think its supposed to be about 25% of our dietary intake, give or take 10% depending on what diet philosophy you want to follow.

We all also need complex carbohydrates for energy for the body and brain, which are found in unprocessed wheat foods, grains, and cereals. Pasta and rice are typical carbs that people eat. I like these. they fill you up and give you energy. Vegetables are also good carbohydrates.

The carbohydrates that we don't need are found in cakes, pancakes, sweets, too many potatos, batters, icecream, chocolate, white bread. These sorts of food are often cooked using lots of butter and other fats so this is another reason to avoid them or at least keep them to minimum. They should not form a large part of a healthy diet.

We need fats too but not much saturated fats as found in fatty meats, deep fried foods, butter and icecream, so keep these to a minimum.

There are some good fats but these should still be eaten in moderation. They are vegetable fats which are usually polyunsaturated fats or monosaturated fats like olive oil. Fatty fish such as salmon, sardines, and so on have omega 3 which everyone raves about. Its recommended to eat fish about twice a week but fishstocks are under threat by overfishing so go easy on wild fish. Good fats are also found in nuts, seeds and avocado. Its ok to eats these yummy foods but limit them. When i eat avocado, i would eat no more than 1/4 of the fruit per day and i often use it on my salad sandwiches instead of butter. If I were to eat nuts, its recommended that you don't eat more than 1/3 cup. That is counted as one serve of protein as they are also high in protein, but be aware that there is a lot of fat in 1/3 cup of nuts. Dieters should eat less than this. Some nuts have much more fat than others. I find it easier to avoid nuts because i can't stop once starting. When eating protein, it should be lean protein. That is meat without a lot of fat attached to it. in your case, i see nothing wrong with eating the skin of chicken but for older dieters or those with a lot of weight to lose, its often recommended they go without the skin.

You've already said you eat a lot of fatty foods. Just give these up and try to eat wholesome meals of vegetables and meat/pasta/rice with only a little fat for cooking. And don't forget your diary products for healthy bones and teeth. Milk and yoghurt are good but don't eat too much cheese as its very high in fat. Eggs are good too.

I still haven't got to the point i wanted to make to you.

My main point

YOu say your extra weight is around your middle. Have you also got skinny legs and small bum? If so it sounds like you are what's called "apple shaped" This is your body type. People with this body type are more prone to developing diabetes and heart disease later in life so they should pay particular attention to maintaining a healthy weight. As said already, you are currently in a healthy weight range. Try to never let your weight get beyond this. If you notice it climbing up, go on a diet. This may not become a matter of concern until you start to have a family or get into your 30s, particularly if you give up regular sport. But just try to remember this bit of advice. If you look around you, notice how all the skinniest women are girls below 20. Everyone puts on weight as they age.

For someone 5 feet 2 inches, you need to stay between 50-62 kilograms or
7stone 12 pounds (112 pounds) and 9 stone 11 pounds (137). If you can do that, you improve your chances of living a long healthy life.

You will only lose fat around your tummy in relation to fat loss all over your body. Because of your body shape you may always have a little more than you wish for on your tummy. Learn to accept. A flat stomach is not everything. I've got a fat bum. Its never going to be pert and cute. But i can still look good in clothes even so. And so can you.
 
Back
Top