National Study Finds Winning Weight-Loss Strategies

bicker

New member
Thought I'd share this story, since I was one of the folks interviewed for it. :D

--------------

Success Stories
National Study Finds Winning Weight-Loss Strategies
ABCNEWS.com

June 2, 2004— Lee Allen just doesn't look at fattening foods the same way anymore.


Before losing 50 pounds, he saw high-calorie, low-nutritional-value foods as simply a delicious meal or snack. But now that Allen is slimmer and wiser, he looks at all food as a numbers game: How many calories does it contain and how long would it take to burn off said calories on the treadmill, Stairmaster or exercise bike?
"I look at a piece of food on the table, I say, 'There's 500 calories, that's 45 minutes, on that machine,' " Allen said.

The battle of the bulge has become a nationwide war, and as American waistlines expand, so do the costs of obesity-related disease, which add up to about $100 billion a year. As Americans spend about $33 billion annually on weight loss products and services, a 10-year study called the National Weight Control Registry has tracked more than 5,000 participants to see how they lost weight and, better yet, how they kept it off.

Funded by the National Institutes of Health and headed up by Dr. Rena Wing, director of The Weight Control and Diabetes Research Center at Miriam Hospital in Providence, R.I., the study collects and analyzes data from successful weight losers. Allen was one of 12 participants from the Boston and Providence-area who spoke to Good Morning America. As a group, they have lost some 950 pounds, and all said the key to their successful weight loss was to stop thinking of weight loss as dieting and instead think of it as a lifestyle change.

"The magic bullet is hard work," Wing said. "It's changing your whole lifestyle, to a healthier eating and exercise approach to living. And that's the only magic bullet we have for long-term weight loss."

The study found that women tend to lose weight in groups, while men tend to lose weight on their own. The dozen subjects are just a fraction of the 5,000 participants in the study, but their backgrounds and weight loss strategies mirror that of the group.

"I always used my kids as an excuse as to why I was overweight," said one participant, Debbie Higgins, who lost 100 pounds. "'Oh, I just had a baby, I just had a baby.' But when they were about 7 it didn't work anymore."

Another woman explained that seeing photographs of herself on vacation was all that it took to get cracking on her diet.

"My husband and I went on a trip to Egypt and [looked] at the pictures when we got back, and I went, 'That cannot possibly be me,' " said Robbie Kohn, who went on to lose 60 pounds.

One Hour of Exercise Daily

Those in the study lost weight in a variety of ways, but to keep it off, researchers found they share key things in common: a low-calorie, low-fat diet and a high level of physical activity. But what was more surprising was the level of exercise it took to keep off the pounds. All 12 said they exercised regularly, and for long periods of time. Three-quarters of the participants walked as a form of exercise.

"They actually report doing large amounts of physical activity, close to an hour a day of physical activity," Wing said. "And that seems to be one of the key characteristics for maintenance of weight loss."

That doesn't mean they immediately embraced exercise.

"I absolutely hated to exercise," Kohn said. "It took me a really long time to get over that, but it's had a lot of rewards. I found myself calmer, I sleep better."

Another woman said that regular exercise not only helped her lose weight, but also helped ease her depression

"I feel that it wasn't the dietary changes that took away the depression, but it was the actual exercise that helped to enhance my mood," said Lori Austin, who lost 100 pounds. "And it was a nice cycle where that helped me to lose the weight. It helped me to eat right."

Margaret Mungovan, another participant, dreaded exercise because it took an hour to 90 minutes out of her day. "One of the best strategies for me has been splitting it up into bouts of physical activity," Mungovan said. "So I can do a walk in the morning, I could do another walk in the evening, and it's not so tedious, and yet I still get that level of physical activity in that helps me manage my weight."

Weigh In Regularly, No Cheating

Another key to success was consistency. Participants who lost weight ate breakfast daily. Those people who did not give themselves a day or two off to cheat were 1 ½ times more likely to maintain their weight loss.

"Perhaps once you start giving yourself some breaks on the weekend, that maybe you start then giving yourself some breaks on Friday, and then maybe Thursday," Wing said. "And little by little, you're taking more breaks and that may be a problem in terms of long-term maintenance of weight loss."

Stepping on the scale regularly can also help. Nearly three-quarters of participants weighed themselves at least once a week.

"It allows them to catch small increases in weight very quickly and take some corrective action," Wing said.

If you think genetics, not willpower, might be hampering your weight loss, think again. Even though about half the people in the registry were overweight as children, and three-quarters had at least one parent that was overweight, they were still able to lose the pounds.

"Childhood obesity and a family history of obesity would suggest a strong genetic predisposition to obesity," Wing said. "So it's very interesting that even despite this genetic predisposition these individuals in the registry have been able to lose weight and keep it off."

Mungovan, who was overweight as a child, remembers the pain of being called names.

"I was the last kid picked at gym class, "she said.

Others said they were not heavy as children.

"As a child I was a pretty skinny little kid," recalled Barbara Fields. "And my family kept saying eat, eat, you got to eat. So I finally ate."

Health Concerns a Strong Impetus

The health risks of being overweight have been well documented. Obesity causes 300,000 deaths a year, and is the second leading cause of preventable deaths in the United States. But those who lose weight for medical reason are much more likely to keep it off. Those in the study who started off for medical reasons only regained half as much weight compared to others who followed over time.

Pauline Marcussen, who lost 100 pounds, said the catalyst was her health-care job in a correctional facility.

"I couldn't run up the three flights of stairs," Marcussen said. "I would get to the top of the stairs and I'd be breathing really hard. And all the officers would be around me saying 'Are you going to have a heart attack?' And I was barely 40 years old at the time."

Henry Olds, who lost 40 pounds, was inspired by his 12-year-old daughter to lose weight and get healthy.

"When I found out I was a stage two diabetic, I really looked at myself and I said, 'You know, I want to stay alive and healthy for that girl,' " Olds said.

The study has also found that those who maintain weight loss for two to five years cut their risk of regaining the weight in half.

Thea Trachtenberg produced this story for Good Morning America.
 
great article. the hardest part for me was getting started exercising (fast walking). no only did i not wanna do it, but physically it hurt like hell. i would have to say it took a full couple of months for my calves to stop hurting. i dont agree with the not cheating tho. i think if i had not allowed myself to cheat occasionally i would have thrown in the towel. i had tried not cheating AT ALL in the past wehn trying to lose weight and i felt so deprived i would end up binging on all the wrong stuff.

i dont think people should let the scale rule their life like i do but its wise to look once a week. the problem for me is the fact that i let myself gain the weihgt in the first place during pregnancy. now i know why celebrities are so careful and get a trainer and stuff so they dont overgain in pregnancy and ruin their body for life. to me, getting to the goal weight is the hardest part wehn u go from 125 most of your life and balloon up to over 200. i think once i get back down to that weihgt it will be much easier to maintain. when i wsa at that low wight i obsessed about it constantly fearing i would get fat, so i never did get fat - until i got pregnant and threw caution to the wind lol!
 
bicker said:
Thought I'd share this story, since I was one of the folks interviewed for it. :D

--------------

Success Stories
National Study Finds Winning Weight-Loss Strategies
ABCNEWS.com

June 2, 2004— Lee Allen just doesn't look at fattening foods the same way anymore.


Before losing 50 pounds, he saw high-calorie, low-nutritional-value foods as simply a delicious meal or snack. But now that Allen is slimmer and wiser, he looks at all food as a numbers game: How many calories does it contain and how long would it take to burn off said calories on the treadmill, Stairmaster or exercise bike?
"I look at a piece of food on the table, I say, 'There's 500 calories, that's 45 minutes, on that machine,' " Allen said.

The battle of the bulge has become a nationwide war, and as American waistlines expand, so do the costs of obesity-related disease, which add up to about $100 billion a year. As Americans spend about $33 billion annually on weight loss products and services, a 10-year study called the National Weight Control Registry has tracked more than 5,000 participants to see how they lost weight and, better yet, how they kept it off.

Funded by the National Institutes of Health and headed up by Dr. Rena Wing, director of The Weight Control and Diabetes Research Center at Miriam Hospital in Providence, R.I., the study collects and analyzes data from successful weight losers. Allen was one of 12 participants from the Boston and Providence-area who spoke to Good Morning America. As a group, they have lost some 950 pounds, and all said the key to their successful weight loss was to stop thinking of weight loss as dieting and instead think of it as a lifestyle change.

"The magic bullet is hard work," Wing said. "It's changing your whole lifestyle, to a healthier eating and exercise approach to living. And that's the only magic bullet we have for long-term weight loss."

The study found that women tend to lose weight in groups, while men tend to lose weight on their own. The dozen subjects are just a fraction of the 5,000 participants in the study, but their backgrounds and weight loss strategies mirror that of the group.

"I always used my kids as an excuse as to why I was overweight," said one participant, Debbie Higgins, who lost 100 pounds. "'Oh, I just had a baby, I just had a baby.' But when they were about 7 it didn't work anymore."

Another woman explained that seeing photographs of herself on vacation was all that it took to get cracking on her diet.

"My husband and I went on a trip to Egypt and [looked] at the pictures when we got back, and I went, 'That cannot possibly be me,' " said Robbie Kohn, who went on to lose 60 pounds.

One Hour of Exercise Daily

Those in the study lost weight in a variety of ways, but to keep it off, researchers found they share key things in common: a low-calorie, low-fat diet and a high level of physical activity. But what was more surprising was the level of exercise it took to keep off the pounds. All 12 said they exercised regularly, and for long periods of time. Three-quarters of the participants walked as a form of exercise.

"They actually report doing large amounts of physical activity, close to an hour a day of physical activity," Wing said. "And that seems to be one of the key characteristics for maintenance of weight loss."

That doesn't mean they immediately embraced exercise.

"I absolutely hated to exercise," Kohn said. "It took me a really long time to get over that, but it's had a lot of rewards. I found myself calmer, I sleep better."

Another woman said that regular exercise not only helped her lose weight, but also helped ease her depression

"I feel that it wasn't the dietary changes that took away the depression, but it was the actual exercise that helped to enhance my mood," said Lori Austin, who lost 100 pounds. "And it was a nice cycle where that helped me to lose the weight. It helped me to eat right."

Margaret Mungovan, another participant, dreaded exercise because it took an hour to 90 minutes out of her day. "One of the best strategies for me has been splitting it up into bouts of physical activity," Mungovan said. "So I can do a walk in the morning, I could do another walk in the evening, and it's not so tedious, and yet I still get that level of physical activity in that helps me manage my weight."

Weigh In Regularly, No Cheating

Another key to success was consistency. Participants who lost weight ate breakfast daily. Those people who did not give themselves a day or two off to cheat were 1 ½ times more likely to maintain their weight loss.

"Perhaps once you start giving yourself some breaks on the weekend, that maybe you start then giving yourself some breaks on Friday, and then maybe Thursday," Wing said. "And little by little, you're taking more breaks and that may be a problem in terms of long-term maintenance of weight loss."

Stepping on the scale regularly can also help. Nearly three-quarters of participants weighed themselves at least once a week.

"It allows them to catch small increases in weight very quickly and take some corrective action," Wing said.

If you think genetics, not willpower, might be hampering your weight loss, think again. Even though about half the people in the registry were overweight as children, and three-quarters had at least one parent that was overweight, they were still able to lose the pounds.

"Childhood obesity and a family history of obesity would suggest a strong genetic predisposition to obesity," Wing said. "So it's very interesting that even despite this genetic predisposition these individuals in the registry have been able to lose weight and keep it off."

Mungovan, who was overweight as a child, remembers the pain of being called names.

"I was the last kid picked at gym class, "she said.

Others said they were not heavy as children.

"As a child I was a pretty skinny little kid," recalled Barbara Fields. "And my family kept saying eat, eat, you got to eat. So I finally ate."

Health Concerns a Strong Impetus

The health risks of being overweight have been well documented. Obesity causes 300,000 deaths a year, and is the second leading cause of preventable deaths in the United States. But those who lose weight for medical reason are much more likely to keep it off. Those in the study who started off for medical reasons only regained half as much weight compared to others who followed over time.

Pauline Marcussen, who lost 100 pounds, said the catalyst was her health-care job in a correctional facility.

"I couldn't run up the three flights of stairs," Marcussen said. "I would get to the top of the stairs and I'd be breathing really hard. And all the officers would be around me saying 'Are you going to have a heart attack?' And I was barely 40 years old at the time."

Henry Olds, who lost 40 pounds, was inspired by his 12-year-old daughter to lose weight and get healthy.

"When I found out I was a stage two diabetic, I really looked at myself and I said, 'You know, I want to stay alive and healthy for that girl,' " Olds said.

The study has also found that those who maintain weight loss for two to five years cut their risk of regaining the weight in half.

Thea Trachtenberg produced this story for Good Morning America.
that is a great website...the shapeup.org... it has more info than one person can digest !
 
Thanks for bumping it up. I did not see it before. I agree, exercise is the hardest. It hurts during and it hurts after, and it takes precious time of your life. Unlike those people who've lost and maintained, I won't have an hour or more every day to dedicate to exercise, its just too much. I think 30 min/day is my maximum, plus whatever I can sqeeze in the morning before work.
 
"a day or two off to cheat were 1 ½ times more likely to maintain their weight loss"

*cries* I like having my reward cheat lol. Good article.
 
I agree 100% with the no cheating/frequent weigh-in stance. When I do cheat, it takes me days and days to get back to where I was before. Now when I think about cheating I ask myself if i really want to spend the time it will take make it up. Frequent weigh-ins help me monitor my behavior. I can see very quickly if I am headed in the wrong direction.

This is a great article. Thank you for bumping it:)
 
This was a very imformative article. I havent lost all my weight yet, but I totally agree with the lifestyle change attitude. My weightloss process got so much easier pshychologically when I decided that I was NOT on a diet. I have decided that this is how I will eat for the rest of my life. When I get to my ideal weight I will have a maintenance diet and allow myself to eat junk and sweets only very seldom and in limited amounts (by that I mean maybe just few times in a year).

I got to that decision by just thinking and contemplating at the whole weightloss and maintaining process and how to achieve what I want - ideal weight. It is in fact very simple... My previous eating habits and food of choice made me FAT once, and they sure will do it again if I go back to them when I have achieved my ideal weight. I will certainly gain all my weight back, twice as fast as it took me to take it off and it isnt even a MAYBE factor. They can and WILL make me fat again. I just had to accept the fact that I cant trust myself to have the freedom of eating everything I want to stick in my mouth. I just have to look back to see what I did with this freedom, I got to a whopping 400+ lbs, 183 kg. Plus the serious overweight I was totally miserable and I put my own life and health at risk.

I have to and I will eat a low-calorie, low-fat, no-sugar, balanced nutrition ALL my life. I was and am a food addict, and I have to keep myself from all my trigger food (everything with sugar in it) my whole life. Just look at it from this point of view. Imagine if a drunk had hit rock bottom and had lost everything because of his drinking. He would make the decision to stop drinking and get a hold of his life again. He would gradually move towards a better life, and at the time he had all the right things going for him, he would make the decision to start drinking again!!!! We all know what the outcome of this would be... This man would end up in exactly the same or worse situation that he was in when he hit rock bottom.

Thats how I look at the weightloss and maintenance of ideal weight. I am not even guessing what will happen, because I see it all around me. Dieting simply doesnt work in the long run, and in fact it will just make things much harder and make your life filled with failure after failure. Who doesnt recognize the evolution of getting the weight off with constantly trying to control the cravings for sweets and junk. If one will lose weight with dieting, maybe even get to ideal weight, the weight will be gained again in record time, when previous eating habits are continued after a period of dieting. I really understand why people get into this vicious cycle because nearly everybody that is overweight desperately wants to lose the weight, but if you dont decide that you cant have both: eating like you do, and that has made you gain weight, and keeping ideal weight. It is like having the cake and eat it too (literally :) ). You simply cant have both!!!! And as long as you dont make the decision on what your really want you will be stuck in the same place. The options are two:
1. Losing weight and gain control of your life by changing the amount and category of food you eat and involve exercise in your daily routine FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE or
2. Experience the food-flavors of the junk (that your mind so strongly connects with well-being and happiness) and stay overweight plus gain weight constantly.

Think about it..........
 
Heidrun,

Thank you for that post. That was an eloquent and powerful message. I am only slowly coming to the understanding that my eating habits of the past must remain in the past. It is so hard to realize that I truly was abusing my body. This change is so hard but it is the only choice.

Congratulations on your 80+ pound loss so far! You are in inspiration.
 
Back
Top