I'm getting confused the more I read about weight lifting

Moon1

New member
At the gym I go to they have a few little articles off the internet on the announcement board. They describe how lifting weights and building muscle is the best way to burn fat. The title of one article is how doing cardio is not the best way to loose weight.

So I read them and have incorporated a weight lifting schedule into my work out. I have been on it for 2 weeks now. 4 days of weights and 3 days of cardio. Each day of weights isolate a different muscle group.

I do not want to build bulk. I want to increase metabolism and increase the amount of calories my body burns resting. Where I am getting confused is on the resting issue. On my cardio days (45 mins on the elliptical) I am not lifting at all. Is this considered "resting" my muscles? I am also watching my diet and I read where a caloric deficit will not grow muscles. So is my weight lifting a waste of time? Should I just focus on cardio until I loose some more weight and can focus on lifting?

Again, I don't want to be a meat head at this point. I just want to do what ever it takes to burn fat and use calories.

ty!
 
well weight lifting will burn calories/fat, but not as much as cardio/eliptical machine will. I too workout on the elliptical on my off lifting days. cardio will rob your muscles of nutrients your muscles need to rebuild. I'm not an expert but my advise would be not to worry about it. you're fine doing cardio on your off days, You're muscles should have plenty of rest before your next lifting day. I would imagine if you're lifting 4 days a week that you're lifting isn't extremely intense or long. I'm kinda in the same boat as you. I'd rather loose more weight than build muscle so it's a no brainer for me. I'll sacrifice a little muscle to burn more fat. I would continue your routine as is. Good work by the way. 7 days a week at the gym is crazy. I go 4, 3 days of lifting and cardio combined and one day of just cardio. Good luck man.
 
You cannot lose weight using Low Fat Diets. Low fat foods have been popular for more than 15 years, but yet our society is getting more overweight as each year passes. This fact alone should tell you that eating a purely low fat menu is not the answer to losing weight.
 
different people lose weight in different ways. cutting the fat might work for some people where as it my not work for the rest. But cutting the fat is a good start. There are alot of diets out there, the trick is to find the diet that fits you.
 
That was spam. The reason people are getting fatter is from eating more fats, more carbs, more everything. Balanced low fat diets are great, just like any balanced diet. Low fat diets have more health benefits than just weight loss.

Spam is bad. Stupidly misleading spam is worse.
 
At the gym I go to they have a few little articles off the internet on the announcement board. They describe how lifting weights and building muscle is the best way to burn fat.

This is a common misnomer.

Building muscle is an intensive process, energetically speaking. Calories are energy. Put differently, in general you need an excess of calories over and above what your body needs to facilitate muscle growth.

Before we get a bunch of guys in here screaming, "Whatever Steve, I've build a ton of muscle while dieting..." let's stop and clarify a couple of points:

1. Most people confuse muscle development while dieting with muscle exposure. Take myself for example. When I'm over 200 lbs, I get a bit softer. When I'm at 185, I appear much bigger and more muscular due to the reduced fat levels. Of course I don't have as much muscle at 185. It's simply a pleasant deception.

2. Getting stronger does not = getting more muscular

3. Untrained and/or people carrying a good bit of fat can, indeed, build muscle and lose fat simultaneously. Shit, I've seen trained people do it too when training has been perfectly matched and genetics are on their side. In all cases though, the muscle development in the face of a deficit will not be very significant or long lived. It's just not the way our bodies work... we're geared for survival of a species and building a lot of muscle during a shortage of energy would not be conducive to survival.

4. Even if you were to build a significant amount of muscle, don't be fooled by what a lot of these 'gurus' are pitching how every pound of muscle burns an additional 50 calories per pound or whatever the going, ridiculous number is nowadays. I've seen it hover between 35 and 100. Point being, building a bunch of muscle in the face of a deficit, if it were possible using natural means, wouldn't make the kind of difference you're expecting.

The title of one article is how doing cardio is not the best way to loose weight.

There's no such thing as One Best Way.

So cardio isn't the best. Nor is weight training.

It takes a multifaceted approach which works synergistically.

So I read them and have incorporated a weight lifting schedule into my work out. I have been on it for 2 weeks now. 4 days of weights and 3 days of cardio. Each day of weights isolate a different muscle group.

It's hard to tell but I doubt your routine is optimal from what you say here. Isolating one body part per workout is usually not the best way to go. At all.

The stickies outline how to set up some example programs that would really do you some good.

I do not want to build bulk.

If bulking were easy, everyone would be walking around with enormous muscles.

Even if your a male (more hormonally and genetically inclined to build muscle) and you're eating a surplus of calories and training perfectly for muscle growth, it's not going to happen to the extent that you're 'bulked' up.

So if you're dieting and training sub-optimally, I sincerely wouldn't be concerned about this AT ALL.

I want to increase metabolism and increase the amount of calories my body burns resting.

See above.

Where I am getting confused is on the resting issue. On my cardio days (45 mins on the elliptical) I am not lifting at all. Is this considered "resting" my muscles?

Depends on how intense your cardio sessions are.

If you're lifting weights and doing high intensity cardio on your 'off training' days, you're giving your body very little chance for recovery and heading down a path to overtraining and overuse injuries.

I am also watching my diet and I read where a caloric deficit will not grow muscles. So is my weight lifting a waste of time?

Sorry, I'm replying as I read along. I covered this above obviously. That said, weight training certainly isn't a waste of time. As I said above, reading through the stickies would do you a lot of good... here is one post found in the stickies pertaining to your question here. Usually I'd simply so "go read the damn stickies" but I was informed by "management" that they want more coddling around here:

http://weight-loss.fitness.com/weight-loss-diary/8425-journey-not-destination-68.html#post207119

This post comes from this thread which I highly suggest you browse through?

http://weight-loss.fitness.com/topic/11337-words-wisdom.html

Should I just focus on cardio until I loose some more weight and can focus on lifting?
 
Thanks a ton. That clears up a lot of my confusion.

It seems so many people are looking to make money off of weight loss and weight lifting I don't know who or what to believe. One book tells you one thing, the guy at the sporting good store just wants you to buy their shit, the gym just wants me to pay for a personal trainer and buy their supplements ...It's like no one is genuinely concerned about helping other people. Thx again.
 
Fitness to the general masses is a pretty new concept/business. It's going to take a while for there to be enough people involved who actually know what they're talking about, having experience and education to lead people correctly.

Until then, you're going to have a lot of bogus information out there. The best you can do is do your own research find people who do know what they're talking about and ask them questions.

Not everyone that makes money in this business is bad. They're just few and far between.

And even the bad ones aren't, for the most part, really bad. They're just ignorant. They have no concept about just how 'off' they are, unfortunately.
 
That was spam. The reason people are getting fatter is from eating more fats, more carbs, more everything. Balanced low fat diets are great, just like any balanced diet. Low fat diets have more health benefits than just weight loss.

Spam is bad. Stupidly misleading spam is worse.

There must be alot of bad stuff in Spam, as I gained alot of weight back when I ate it for breakfast. It sure does taste good when you fried it up 'long with some taters and onions though!:rolleyes:
 
Back
Top