Mental = Psychiatry/Psychology
I agree, Korrie. Walking in the shoes paints the sort of picture others probably aren't going to be able to understand. I don't think it's so black and white, though. With some of the hyper-obese clients I've worked with closely, I've felt their pain and struggles. Their trials and tribulations become my own, which I think any quality professional will attest to. But even with that, the professional can never fully understand.
Like I said though, it's not black and white... understand or not understand. I think it's somewhere in the middle.
If it's a matter of understanding the mechanics of the brain, then I think it's a matter of dealing with professionals of the brain. Psychiatric research has done advanced imaging of brains of obese vs. lean subjects, for instance.
My point is, the solution is extremely multi-faceted. Experience is just one minor facet of the solution. And said experience can come from walking in the shoes or working with those who have walked in the shoes.
And besides, obesity is climbing at ridiculous rates. With more and more obese people in the world, if it took the experience of being obese to solve the problem, you'd think the problem would start to reverse since the prevalence of said problem has grown to the extent it has.
It's like I say. Some of us on this forum are going to get cancer. If it's you, are you going to seek the doctor who has had cancer or the doctor who has the most knowledge and best track record with his patients?
I don't like binary thinking... I don't think either extreme view is right. I think communities like this are great. You have some very knowledgeable people, some who have battled obesity, some who have not. In addition, you have people who aren't that knowledgeable but who've accomplished quite a bit of weight loss. The experience of both parties makes for better chances than either party alone.
Sorry for the rambles!