shawnnam
New member
I don't think anyone is categorically offended. It's clear that you aren't overtly advocating addictive drugs to lose weight.
In the spirit of information sharing; I would however take issue with your legal/illegal mental health comment. The criteria for approving drugs is, as you may or may not be aware, a source of great debate.
Whether a drug is deemed legal or illegal, available by prescription or over-the-counter, does not account for it's safety nor does it speak to anyone's mental health for their decision to take it. Some will take a medicine simply because it's for sale, without any regard for the faulty system which led it to be there.
This is just one example, and superficial at that, but [link removed], marketed as a cold medicine, comes to mind. It's a strong and effective medicine which happens to have psychoactive ingredients. If you read the ingredients and potential side affects, few could help but wonder what the criteria for a "safe" and "legal" drug mixture is. Would you give your child LSD? Speed? Meth? No? Then why would you give your kid this "medicine"? Moreover, why would the government ever approve this specific elixir for sale, over-the-counter no less? The answer is money. The pharmaceutical lobby is very powerful.
Only recently, [link removed] changed their formula to make their product "more accessible to consumers". It turns out meth-labs were using this product to make meth and while the makers of Dimetapp were okay with that, the government wasn't. The formula wasn't changed because the previous one was deemed unsafe or illegal, rather because the government banned the "ease of access" to medicines which had the psychoactive ingredients hoping to curb illicit drug making. The formula still includes a type of addictive stimulant, but the meth-heads can't use it to make their drugs.
In short, I don't buy into the legal/illegal argument. The system and criteria for categorizing drugs is entirely faulty, driven by corporate greed, and shouldn't be used as a measure of mental health.
We don't question the mental health of people who implicitly trust powerful government agencies who work in co-operation with powerful, greedy, extremely wealthy corporations, do we? Or do we?![]()
I was actually referring to someone who is not eating to lose weight or is excessively working out to lose weight being a mental health issue, I know because I suffered from it, I didn't even have an eating disorder but suffered from sever depression which caused me to see my body differently that what I should, because of that I starved myself and worked out multiple times a day.
I would say when it comes to weight loss drugs it is more of a matter of safety. Some may be safe and some may not, because the FDA only approves certain ones we really don't know what is safe or not, and not only that the ones they have approved are not really proven to be that safe either. So I agree, it is a big debate, but for what you are speaking of in terms of mental health I was referring to actual mental health with how someone eats or exercises or sees themselves.