Sport diet help

Sport Fitness
so im starting a new diet today and i have some qualms with it but ultimately i was sold by my trainer (the person who wants me on it) who was so passionate behind his belief that it was the best possible diet.

the diet is one that follows the belief that the different food types ie proteins, carbs, oils and etc should be digested seperately with the exception of a few " nuetral" foods. my diet will consist of mainly fuits ,veggies, plain oatmeal, buck weat and potatoes with some fish thrown in as well. my concern was the reduction in protein as i do lift weights however he believes (and i have found some studies to back him up) that our bodies don tneed as much protein as one might believe. my main goal for right now is indeed weight loss. this diet combined with high intensity training is what he believes is the most efficent method for weight loss. do you guys see any flaws in his logic?
 
Just going by my understanding of how digestion works, eating your carbs, proteins, and fats separately will not significantly improve your digestion.

As for protein, I don't know how much of it to eat and so can't say if you should cut back on it or not. The average person needs 1-2g of protein per kg of their bodyweight though. Also, typically, when you're losing weight, you should generally keep your protein levels around they are and reduce your carbs (not telling you to go on Atkins, though) as carbs are more often than not the macro that's eaten in excess and becoming stored.
 
Biggest clue to ideal balance is in your mouth. Teeth small canines meaning little need for tearing meat, so this should be the lowest part, flattish teath at the back but not real big grinders set up for lots of highly fibrous foods, more set for higher quality roots, seeds etc. Saliva incredibly high in amylase, the enzyme responsible for breaking down starch to glucose, the biggest and most ignored clue that we are designed for a diet high in complex carbohydrate to such an extent we start working on it as chewing.

Seperating is a good way of avoiding you gettign to hungry by always having food in your stomach, but this could be done without by having smaller meals, it really makes no difference. It aslo will not cause harm so by all means try it.

Balance is something the western world gets so far off that it's insane. We eat far too much fat, protein, salt and of course sugar, meaning the very thing we have evolved for which is high starch diet has been turned on it's head. Because people don't seem to identify the difference between high sugar diet and high carb diet the low carb diet is promoted as the way to go.
When it comes to treatment of injuries etc. I always bow down to Jrahiens greater knowledge. Today it's nutrition and that is my arena, having studied it from perspective of sports, evolution, anatomy and many other directions I have learned how insanely we eat and how simple getting it right should be and isn't. All this and I still get it wrong.

There are very few ways in which food affects metabolism as it enters the body, but intake of carbs is the main one. We are designed to get most of our energy from carbs so the body judges what is coming in by how much carbohydrate we take in simple or complex. Drastically reducing this tells the body we have hit lean times and the metabolism is dropped to keep us alive, we feel the need to seek sweet food when this happens.
Excess carbs become fat, as much as it can excess protein becomes fat, and excess fat doesn't need to be converted. Carbs are the first energy source to be used so it is the easiest to avoid going to store. Eating too much makes you more likely to get fat, which type of energy is less important in this case.
Excessive intake of simple carbs aka sugars is dangerous in many ways and I strongly urge you not to do this ever. It is a great way to gain a lot of weight by totally messing with your insulin curve, driving up your apettite up and forcing your body to store a barely controlable influx of energy as fat.
Complex carbs aka starch are slow release and if eaten in small quantities throughout the day will keep you metabolism up, energy levels high and with a good training program avoid more than a minimal amount being stored as fat with more being stored using glycogen.

The high protein diet has been used to death because the Joe Weider clones have been promoting it on the basis that muscle is made of protein. For one thing muscle is 3/4 water, for another you will need more protein if you are training but this will be proportionate to the amount of extra energy you need to fuel training, recovery and new muscle tissue, so supplementing or increasing protein out of proportion will not help. The excess that cannot be converted to fat will be dispose dof the same was as excess water, in the urine.
 
Avoid any carbohydrate that is — or can be — white. The following foods are thus prohibited, except for within 1.5 hours of finishing a resistance-training workout of at least 20 minutes in length: bread, rice, cereal, potatoes, pasta, and fried food with breading. If you avoid eating anything white, you’ll be safe.

Rule #2: Eat the same few meals over and over again

The most successful dieters, regardless of whether their goal is muscle gain or fat loss, eat the same few meals over and over again. Mix and match, constructing each meal with one from each of the three following groups:

Proteins:
Egg whites with one whole egg for flavor
Chicken breast or thigh
Grass-fed organic beef
Pork

Legumes:
Lentils
Black beans
Pinto beans

Vegetables:
Spinach
Asparagus
Peas
Mixed vegetables

Eat as much as you like of the above food items. Just remember: keep it simple. Pick three or four meals and repeat them. Almost all restaurants can give you a salad or vegetables in place of french fries or potatoes. Surprisingly, I have found Mexican food, swapping out rice for vegetables, to be one of the cuisines most conducive to the “slow carb” diet.
 
3.5 million years of evolution totally ignored. Our main natural diet is starchy food, it is what we are designed to get most of our calories from. A lotof it is white because starch is white. If the statement was to avoid bleached products or advised wholegrain as the ideal I would be totally with you, but all slow carbs or complex carbohydrates are starch, which is white, so the white stuff coming out of your cut potato is the very thing advised here.

Egg whites with one yolk for flavour. Unless you cook them the yolk contains the enzymes making the protein in the white digestable, so it's not for flavour it so avoid the protein coming out in your faeces.

Diet can be as varied as you like as long as the nutritional values remain roughly constant. The very key to our survival has been our ability to adapt to various diets. We need our calorific content to be 60-65% carbs (95% complex, 5 %max sugars), 25% fats, 17.5% protein or to. If this comes from pasta, beef and vegetables or fuit, beans, soy and variety of veg. What matters is what the food contains and iseally that we enjoy it so we can stick to the way we eat.

The main thing I try to get people to think of when looking at diet is whether they would be happy eating this for life. If that's no then failure is just around the corner.
 
Back
Top