I'm not a novice, I have lifted on and off for the past 10 years. Last time I seriously lifted was about 2 years ago.
That makes you a novice.
Coming back from a two year hiatus from lifting can lead to simultaneous recomp.
I am aware that "strength gains don't mean bigger muscles" thats why I said that not only have my lifts increased (i.e. strength) but so have my arms/quads (size). So no matter how you want to quantify it I have increased lean mass.
I'm not going to play the semantics card with you.
You say you have... nice work.
I should couch the phrase "you need a caloric surplus to gain muscle" with "in most cases because of X, Y, and Z."
Frankly I just don't have the time.
And concurrent recomp is not something most people should expect.
Hypertrophy is a very intensive process, energetically speaking. When you're dieting, you don't have enough calories to preserve what you currently have in terms of tissue...
So if you're suggesting it's common for people to simultaneously gain muscle and lose fat outside the realms of novice-hood or overweightness, you might want to reconsider.
n=1 in terms of your experience doesn't carry a lot of weight.
I've worked with countless people and it's no different each time... outside that realm from above.
Unfortunately I didn't measure my arms/quads right at the start, however since I lived in this body for 40 years I am pretty darn familiar with it. I can safely say that both arms & legs have gained quite a bit. I would estimate an inch (or more) on my arms.
If you've gained an inch on your arms while eating hypocalorically, you are blessed genetically.
There's no other way to slice it.
Since I have been measuring my arms have gone up by almost .5". Sleeves on t-shirts are now tight, same thing with legs on boxer-briefs.
Good job!
I believe I am very average, particularly since I'm 40, so if higakun is younger he will probably have more Testosterone
You keep reverting back to T.
T isn't the be all end all to hypertrophy.
And no, you shouldn't outlay your n=1 experience to everyone else.
and can expect (yes I used the word "expect") to succeed at both muscle gains and fat loss.
Certainly, assuming he's a novice or fat.
If not, he shouldn't expect it but if it happens... awesome.